The E-Sylum v6#14, April 6, 2003
whomren at coinlibrary.com
whomren at coinlibrary.com
Sun Apr 6 20:26:30 PDT 2003
Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 6, Number 14, April 6, 2003:
an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
Copyright (c) 2003, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
SUBSCRIBER UPDATE
Among recent new subscribers are Bill D'Atri, courtesy of
Dick Hanscom of Fairbanks, Alaska. Welcome aboard!
We now have 541 subscribers.
JOHN J. FORD COLLECTION AND LIBRARY
NBS Board member P. Scott Rubin writes: "This is good news
and bad news. The good news is that starting as early as later
this year the entire collection of John J. Ford, Jr. is coming up
for sale by Stack's and yes the library will be sold by Stack's
and George Kolbe. While it will take some time before the full
impact of what is in this collection to be announced, it is my
understanding that if you collect colonial coins or paper, U.S.
Paper, numismatic literature, medals, or pioneer gold you will
not want to miss this sale. This may well be the Bushnell or
Parmelee sale of the 21st century. The bad news is that this
looks like the end of the John Ford era in U.S. numismatics.
John has been a good friend to NBS and we hope he will be
around for some time. But just the thought that he is parting
with his collection is hard to take, even though I will look
forward to the catalogues and the chance to own an item or
two from John's library or collection. Look for more
information on the sales in the numismatic press."
CONFEDERATE BOOK UPDATES
George Tremmel writes: "Thanks for the mention of my new
CSA counterfeit currency book. (Actually, its length is 198
pages, rather than 144.)
[I ordered the book from Hugh Shull on Monday, and
by the end of the week it was in my hands. After only a
short review I'm convinced it was the best $35 I've spent
in some time. The book is very well illustrated, with two or
more good quality black & white illustrations on nearly every
page of the catalog section. The 70-page Part I "Historical
Narrative" makes excellent reading, and the book has
endnotes for every chapter as well as a bibliography.
-Editor]
Concerning the late Doug Ball's CSA currency manuscript, it
was a joint effort with Hugh Shull. I believe that Hugh plans
to complete the book and bring it to publication - certainly
good news."
[It's a relief and a pleasure to learn that Ball's manuscript
may yet be published - very good news indeed. -Editor]
FROM THE SHORES OF SAN SERIFFE
An email making the rounds of the Internet on April Fool's
Day stated:
"In 1977, the British newspaper "The Guardian" published a
seven-page supplement to honor the 10th anniversary of
San Serriffe, a republic in the Indian Ocean consisting of
several semi-colon-shaped islands.
Its two main islands were Upper Caisse and Lower Caisse;
its capital was Bodoni, and its leader was General Pica.
Few "Guardian" readers, who rang up the offices all day
asking about the idyllic spot, noted the use of printer's
terminology."
Your Editor's first introduction to the Republic of San Seriffe
spoof came with the publication of "The First Fine Silver
Coinage of the Republic of San Seriffe" by Henry Morris of
Bird & Bull Press. 350 copies were produced, each containing
a one-ounce serially-numbered silver proof commemorative
coin and certificate of authenticity. This is one book I don't
yet have in my library, as it's pricey and not exactly in my line
of interest. But it sounds fun. If any of our readers have a
copy, could you tell us if Morris acknowledges the 1977
Guardian article? Is the reference to the 1977 article correct,
or yet another Internet spoof? Gawd, I'm confused.
Morris also published "The Booksellers of San Seriffe" in 2001,
which, if I'm not mistaken, includes a token of George Frederick
Kolbe, Bookseller.
The April Fool email seems to have been cribbed from the
"Museum of Hoaxes" web site, which notes:
"At the Guardian itself the island of San Serriffe became a
running gag in the years to follow. The island reappeared on
April Fool's Day in 1978, 1980 and 1999. Moreover, each
time it reappeared the island had changed location. It began
in the Indian Ocean, moved to the South China Sea, and
ended up in the North Atlantic. "
http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/af_1977.html
For amusement, read the site's list of the "Top 100" Hoaxes.
Be sure to check out #10, "The Predictions of Isaac Bickerstaff,"
which was perpetrated by Jonathan Swift.
http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/top100.html
Quick Quiz: Who can tell us Swift's connection to American
numismatics?
1871 MINTAGE FIGURES
Bob Julian writes: "Recently there was a query about the
mintage figures for the 1871 quarter, presumably Philadelphia.
The material on mintages for the Philadelphia quarters of
1853-1873, based on research in the original registers at the
Archives, appeared in the June 1965 Numismatic Scrapbook
Magazine. For those not having access to this issue, the
entries were as follows:
January 10 36,000
May 11 45,000
August 3 37,200
Plus 960 proofs.
Total: 119,160 pieces."
NEW U.S. PATTERN PHOTOS ONLINE
Saul Tiechman writes: "Here are some interesting die trials
in the Smithsonian that many people have not seen.
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3058.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/sip3176.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3212.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3305.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3383.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3425.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3437.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3440.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3443.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3444.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3465.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3486.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p3524.html
http://uspatterns.com/uspatterns/p2080.html "
CONSIMILAR: BOTH SIDES ALIKE.
P. Scott Rubin writes: As to coins with the same design,
but not the same dies, Alaska Rural Rehabilitation Corporation
Tokens of 1935, listed in the Red Book, were stuck this way.
All eight tokens. The one Cent was not round as like the
others but had eight sides, for another odd piece of Americana.
Dick Johnson writes: "You are correct in surmising there are
tokens and medals with identical designs on both sides. I can't
speak for coins with identical sides.
There is even a word for describing such numismatic items:
CONSIMILAR. Meaning both sides alike. The dies can be
made from the same hub, model, punch or master pattern.
American copyist and medalist James Bolen did this a lot (and
you should hear from Bolen authority Neil E. Musante about
these). An example of Bolen's handiwork is Musante JAB-34,
the Double Elephant Token.
I know of only one instance of medals from my days of
cataloging the work of Medallic Art Company. In 1962
sculptor John Terken (1912-1993) made one model for a
MONY Client Service Medal (MAco 62-108). They
wanted both sides alike. We could have cut a hub from a
positive of Terken's model, then had two dies made from that
hub. But hubbing is specialized and requires a modern
hubbing press. Instead of owning our own hubbing press we
always subcontracted the hubbing to one of the tool and die
shops we worked with. So instead of having a hub made, we
just went ahead and cut two dies from a negative die shell of
Terken's model. We did this in our own plant on one of the
five Janvier die-engraving pantographs we had at the time.
[A hubbing press is a dangerous machine. If you don't know
what you are doing, too much pressure can cause a die to
shatter. It sends out shrapnel in all directions. We had 1,000-ton
presses, the worst that could happen with these is to lose a
finger. You can get killed from a hubbing press!]
But why would anyone want the same design on both sides?
(Do I need to answer? Do you always want heads to come
up?) In Bolen's and similar cases, they used dies of similar
diameter to create yet another specimen for you variety-
hungry numismatists!
Kavan Ratnatunga sends these links to interesting images of
coins with the same obverse and reverse. Dutch Ceilon 1660-
1720 Wreath Series Copper Dumps and 1785 Ceylan Bonk
bar - Colombo VOC 4 3/4 Stuiver
http://serendib.org/coins/dutch/wreath_cud.html
http://serendib.org/coins/lingen/1785_voc_c_4.75st_cub.html
A related discussion appears on this page:
http://serendib.org/coins/egroup/obverse_reverse.html
MICKLEY CATALOG VARIANTS
P. Scott Rubin writes: "About the Mickley sale differences.
It should also be noted that while many copies are hand
priced only those with the title page stating Priced
Catalogue were hand priced after the sale by Woodward
or more likely his sons or employees. The others were
either pre-sales copies priced at the sale or after the sale
by copying the prices from someone else's copy."
NATIONAL ARCHIVES ONLINE ACCESS
Over 50 million historical records at the National Archives
are available online at http://www.archives.gov/aad/.
"The Access to Archival Databases (AAD) System gives you
online access to electronic records that are highly structured,
such as in databases. The initial release of AAD contains
material from more than 30 archival series of electronic
records, which include over 350 data files totaling well over
50 million unique records. The series selected for AAD
identify specific persons, geographic areas, organizations, or
dates. Some of these series serve as indexes to accessioned
archival records in non-electronic formats."
Who knows what nuggets await numismatic researchers in
these newly available archives? Gentlemen, start your
search engines!
NUMISMATIC ETHICS
David Lange writes: "I've never found anything of value inside
a book, other than the information it contained, but I have had
some interesting finds with the coin albums I collect. I go
through whatever stock of old albums a dealer may have for
sale at a show or in his shop, and it's not unusual to find a few
lingering coins within albums that the dealer was certain were
empty. Since my interest is in the albums alone, I always
inform him of the find and offer to remove the coins.
Even then, metal discs may be lurking unseen. I once dropped
a National brand album page for two-cent and three-cent
pieces that I'd acquired a few years earlier. After reassuring
myself that the corners had not been bent, I was surprised to
discover three silver trimes projecting partway into their
respective holes. So thin were these worn coins that they had
slipped between the cardboard and the paper covering,
escaping notice until the sudden jolt of hitting the floor
dislodged them from their seclusion."
George Kolbe writes: "Another great issue. Over the years I
have found a number of unusual things in books, though it is
not a common occurrence. Thin coins, including gold ones,
currency from many countries and eras, and pressed plants
and flowers are among the objects discovered. When items
of value have been found in books sent for auction, they have
been promptly returned to the consignor. When encountered
in books purchased outright, disposition has varied with the
circumstances. Once, the seller of a very large library called
to inquire if a very rare postage stamp had been found in one
of his volumes. I did not find it but would have felt duty bound
to return it if I had. If indeed it was present in one of the
volumes, there was a very lucky buyer.
Perhaps the most memorable item ever found was in a nice
library purchased years ago from a collector living alone in a
remote town in the California desert. It was a letter to his then
wife complaining about the paucity of their love life. It took
little time to determine that it was not going to be returned,
and it quickly found its way to the circular file.
A story about John Selden, the seventeenth century British
scholar and numismatic author, also touches on the topic.
Selden used his spectacles as bookmarks, and apparently
often forgot that he had done so. His library was left to the
Bodleian Library at Oxford, and when the books were
examined by the library staff, dozens of pairs of his spectacles
were found therein."
Our discussion of numismatic literature deals led into a
discussion of the larger area of numismatic transactions. Dick
Johnson wrote: "When someone offers you an item in your
specialty and it is mispriced, what do you do? Does it matter
if this person is a professional dealer or a lay person?"
In response, Denis Loring writes: "My personal rules are as
follows:
Seller a professional dealer simply offering me material:
caveat vendor. If I can cherrypick a rare variety or an
undergraded coin, good for me. Exception: if it's someone
I've done extensive business with over time, I'll tell him what
he's got, confident we'll work something out.
Seller a lay person who has priced material or asks me for
an offer, not knowing my specialty: try to find a middle
ground between ripping the person off and paying full price.
ANYONE, whether a novice or a pro, who asks me:
"Denis, you're a large cent specialist, are there any rare
varieties here?": My offer is this: I provide attribution and fair
value gratis, and I get first refusal at a fair price for any good
ones I find. Especially to a lay person, I bend over backwards
to explain to him exactly what he has and how it's valued."
TOLL GATE DIGS
Joe Wolfe writes: "This is an article I wrote for a metal
detecting club's monthly newsletter and thought you might
want it for The E-Sylum also. It would demonstrate some
of the research successful coin shooters do to find coins or
caches and provide a little background on where those
dropped coins come from."
[I've edited the article a bit to cut down its size, but
the main points remain. -Editor]
"One source of sites to search for old coins are tollgates on
pre-1900s turnpikes. The word turnpike by definition contains
tollgates which were the collection points of tolls on the early
Virginia roads. ... I believe people dropped coins around the
tollgates, in the road, at the tollgate, and on the way to the
tollkeeper's house. Remember the tolls were collected all year
long, even during storms, snow, sunrise, and sunset. So a coin
dropped in the mud, snow, or dark could be easily lost.
In my research I concentrated on Fairfax and Loudoun Counties
but turnpikes exist all over Virginia and in other states. I found
15 different turnpikes.
The single and best source for tollgate locations are old maps.
Not only do they list tollgates but they show the exact location,
the path of the turnpike, place a date on the tollgate, and often
provide the name of the tollkeeper. All these can help to
pinpoint the tollgate. Other sources include books, articles, and
archives for the old turnpike companies. Archives exist in several
local libraries and the State Library in Richmond. The State
Library also has an unpublished manuscript on Virginia Turnpikes.
But maps are the best and this is where I would direct you.
Tollgates were usually authorized every five miles and were
often located near bridges and crossroads. I assume this was
to prevent travelers from bypassing the tollgates. The bridge
created a bottleneck in the road and the crossroads allowed
tolls to be collected from everyone passing by. Tollgates
often changed locations as new roads opened and when the
tolltaker changed. Often a person already living in the area
was selected to be the tolltaker and the tollgate moved to his
house. So the tollgate near Difficult Run might have four
different locations, both sides of the road and both sides of
the stream. Of course a map only shows a snapshot of the
tollgates on a turnpike on a certain date. If an old house
exists next to a substantial stream it may be an undocumented
tollgate. I should mention I found the modern reproduction
maps from various sources of data to be worse than useless.
They seemed to place the word "tollgate" on the map where
it was most convenient to write it.
I have visited many of these tollgates and I am sorry to say
many are covered by asphalt. As our use of roads developed
the roads were widened and the tollgate covered. The
collection point was often located right next to the road. The
grading of the shoulders of roads also took care of many.
The best to detect are the ones where the tollhouse still
stands or its ruins can be found.
One final point is there are still many tollgates around. I found
over 50 locations in Loudoun and Fairfax alone and according
to its annual report the Little River Turnpike, circa 1830,
made over $100,000 in its busiest year.
I am still searching for an untouched tollgate and have found
only a few coins so far. The oldest was a 1773 pillar dollar
that was paper-thin."
THE NASTY OLD BOOK I THREW AWAY
Granvyl G. Hulse, Jr. writes: "I saw this joke today and just
couldn't resist sending it on.
A collector of rare books ran into an acquaintance who told
him he had just thrown away an old Bible that he found in a
dusty, old box. He happened to mention that
Guten-somebody-or-other had printed it.
"Not Gutenberg?" gasped the collector.
"Yes, that was it!"
"You idiot! You've thrown away one of the first books ever
printed. A copy recently sold at auction for half a million dollars!"
"Oh, I don't think this book would have been worth anything
close to that much," replied the man. "It was scribbled all over
in the margins by some guy named Luther."
BOOK DEALING AS A PROFESSION
Numismatic literature dealer John Burns had a table at the
Baltimore coin show a few weeks ago. Leaving the hall to
meet John Kraljevich and fellow dealer Charles Davis, he
was stopped by a panhandler who asked, "Can you spare
something, sir?" Well, John's not exactly the last of the big
spenders, and sales at the show up to that point had been at
best so-so. So John said to the woman, "Why don't you
get a job like everyone else?"
"But I don't got no skills!" came her reply, and John blurted
out, "I don't have any damn skills, either - why do you think
I'm a BOOKDEALER!?" Charlie nearly spewed his beer
laughing when he heard the tale, but according to John, they
both stopped suddenly, thinking, what are we laughing about?
[The above was related over the phone by John Burns,
who doesn't have an email account, but agreed to share the
story with our readers. -Editor]
FEATURED WEB PAGE
This week's featured web page is about the Barnstaple Shilling
of Barnstaple, North Devon, "the oldest Borough Town in
Britain."
"The tradition whereby the Mayor of Barnstaple presents coins
to the inhabitants of the almshouses and residential homes in
the town soon after he has been elected to office probably has
its origins in the will of Henry Gardner Tippett who died in
1795."
"... the tradition of presenting coins to the almshouse residents
has continued, albeit in a different form, to the present day.
Now it is the Mayor who distributes the coins. A sixpence
used to be given but following the introduction of decimalisation
and the later withdrawal of that coin a five-pence piece was
used."
http://www.barnstaple-history.co.uk/barnstaple_shilling.htm
Wayne Homren
Numismatic Bibliomania Society
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a
non-profit organization promoting numismatic
literature. For more information please see
our web site at http://www.coinbooks.org/
There is a membership application available on
the web site. To join, print the application and
return it with your check to the address printed
on the application. For those without web access,
write to David Sklow, NBS Secretary-Treasurer,
P.O. Box 76192, Ocala, FL 34481.
For Asylum mailing address changes and other
membership questions, contact Dave at this email
address: sdsklow at aol.com
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum,
just Reply to this message, or write to the Editor
at this address: whomren at coinlibrary.com
(To be removed from the E-Sylum mailing list
send an email message with the word "Unsubscribe"
in the body of the message to:
esylum-request at binhost.com)
More information about the Esylum
mailing list