The E-Sylum v6#55, December 28, 2003

whomren at whomren at
Sun Dec 28 19:31:45 PST 2003

Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 6, Number 55, December 28, 2003:
an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
Copyright (c) 2003, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.


   Dick Johnson writes: "At the beginning of a new year, we
   pause to reflect on the gem we all share in The E-Sylum.

   For the numismatic book collector, for whom it was originally
   intended, The E-Sylum has become a “must read.”  But The
   E-Sylum  has grown beyond its service to the NB collector.

   For numismatic writers E-Sylum has become a treasured tool;
   not only does it provide article ideas, but research capabilities
   beyond compare in the collective knowledge of  its 612
   subscribers. (Ask a question one week, you're bound to get
   a knowledgeable answer the next!).

   For serious numismatists it's a unique means of keeping
   up-to-date that printed coin publications cannot match in such
   a timely manner.  For the entire numismatic field The E-Sylum
   is an international treasure.

   Thank you Wayne Homren for doing this every week.   And
   thanks also to NBS for your sponsorship."

   [Happy New Year, all.  Putting The E-Sylum together each
   week is a chore, but an enjoyable one.  Our subscribers are
   an interesting and talented bunch, and I get to look forward
   your emails every day!   Please help out by encouraging
   friends to subscribe, answering a query or submitting a new
   item or topic of interest.   -Editor]


   As discussed in the December 14, 2003 E-Sylum (v6#53),
   plans are underway for a special outing to celebrate the 25th
   anniversary of NBS at next year's ANA convention in
   Pittsburgh. "We'll visit the E-Sylum Ground Zero (my library),
   as well as the numismatic libraries of Asylum Editor
   E. Tomlinson Fort and the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh.
   The latter features the rare first six volumes of the ANA's
   Numismatist magazine, and a shelf of early U.S. copper
   literature from the library of George H. Clapp.

   Separately, if there is enough interest, we may be able to
   arrange a viewing of selected coins from the Carnegie
   collection, which includes Clapp's Large Cent collection,
   some colonials, and some U.S. patterns."

   For those who may have missed the previous request,
   please email me if you have interest in the BOOK trip, the
   COIN trip, or BOTH.   The convention is August 18-22,
   2004.   My address is whomren at


   Steve Huber writes: "I've been told there is a new reference
   for Geddenk Talers.  These are German medals about the size
   of a U.S. Half minted from about 1890 through 1930.  Many
   memorialized war efforts and officers in 1914/1915.  Not only
   can I not locate any source for such a new reference but cannot
   locate any specific reference on the subject.  Can anyone help
   me locate such a reference?  Thanks."


   The catalog of the January 5-6, 2004 Classics sale from
   American Numismatic Rarities makes for interesting reading.
   The sale opens with another nice selection of U.S. pattern
   coins and ends with the Thomas H. Sebring collection of
   shipwreck coins and related items.  The Sebring collection
   has a two-page introduction by Bob Evans of the S.S. Central
   America recovery team.  In addition to recovered coins and
   ingots, the consignment features related medals, including the
   1858 medal struck for the state of Virginia to honor the
   Central America's heroic captain William Lewis Hearndon.

   For bibliophiles, lot 1666 is a deluxe leatherbound version of
   Q. David Bowers' 2002 "A California Gold Rush History."
   ".. front endpapers include a pinch of 'authentic gold dust from
   the Central America' protected behind plastic in the miner's
   pan of the illustrated scene - a nice touch, inspired by the
   1849 second edition of the 1842 'A Manual of Gold and
   Silver Coins of All Nations' and the '1850 New VArieties of
   Gold and Silver Coins' bu Jacob R. Eckfeldt and William E.
   DuBois of the Philadelphia Mint, works which included a
   specimen of California gold dust behind a mica window....
   This edition cost nearly $1,000 per copy to produce.."

   The catalog includes an essay by John Kraljevich,
   "My Friend Tom Sebring."  John describes meeting
   Sebring when attending his first coin show in West Chester,
   PA at age 10 in 1988.  Sebring invited John to join the
   local coin club, which he did, and had the chance to see
   and learn from Tom and other experienced numismatists
   every month for the next seven years.

   Related to a recent E-Sylum topic, the auction also
   includes a 1783 Chalmers Shilling (lot 1039).  From the
   lot description:  "The recent discovery of a Chalmers
   threepence in the basement of a house on the street
   where Chalmers lived in 1783, covered in such papers
   as the Washington Post and Baltimore Sun, has led to
   speculation that the basement was the site of Chalmers'
   mint.  While the discovery is an exciting one, the presence
   of a single coin is not persuasive evidence of minting activity,
   particularly in the absence of silver scrap, minting equipment
   or tools, or other implements manufactured by Chalmers.
   We prefer the historical record, which notes an outbuilding
   present on property that Chalmers actually owned and
   occupied up the street from the location of the recent


   An ad in the January 5, 2004 issue of Coin World (p70)
   offers a new book by Robert J. Loewinger, M.D. titled
   "Proof Gold Coinage of the United States."  It is a
   hardcovered 128 page book measuring 7.75" x 10.5",
   with 136 full color illustrations.  A article by Paul Gilkes
   (p3) notes that Dr. Loewinger will have "an extensive
   exhibit of high-grade type Proof gold to be displayed
   Jan. 8 to 11 during the Florida United Numismatists
   convention in Orlando."


   The January 5, 2004 Coin World also includes a Guest
   Commentary by Roger W. Burdette, where he notes:
   "During the past four years, I have examined thousands
   of documents on the subject of the Mint Bureau's
   subsidiary silver coin redesign of 1916 and 1917.  This
   research is in preparation of the book, "Renaissance of
   American Coinage, 1916-1921."  Research has involved
   primary sources in manuscript collections of academic,
   art, government and private archives."   We will look
   forward to the publication of Burdette's research, which
   should be an interesting look at a period of important
   change in the nation's coinage.


   Arthur Shippee thought the following URL would be of
   interest.  It's a web log (or "blog") being used by the author
   to publish a coin a day from his collection of ancient coins.
   The text is brief, but the images are great.

   He also writes: "The following links are from Explorator, a
   weekly collection of web-posted news about the pre-Modern
   world.  (See

   Here's one to build a crackpot theory on ... a Roman coin was
   found during construction in New Zealand:


   Regarding the 1862 U.S. Mint pricelist discussed last week,
   Rich Hartzog writes: "Interesting!  May I inquire if any of the
   Indian Peace medals were available in silver?

   Thanks!  The E-Sylum is 'must' reading.  I may just have to
   break down and join NBS..."

   [Please do!    NBS is far more than just The E-Sylum.  Only
   members receive our quarterly print journal, the Asylum.  NBS
   also sponsors meetings and literature symposia at major coin
   shows around the U.S.   If you like The E-Sylum, you'll love
   the in-depth articles and talks your NBS membership supports.
   I welcome all non-member E-Sylum readers to consider making
   NBS your New Year's resolution for 2004.  Membership is only
   $15 per year to North American addresses, and $20 elsewhere.
   As always, information on joining NBS may be found at the end
   of this email message.  -Editor]

   Jan Monroe writes: "I am also very interested in getting a copy
   of the 1862 Mint price list.  This list may shed some light on the
   silver medals available to the public.  I would think it worth
   publishing in the Asylum."

   [Here are the silver medals offered in the pricelist:

   Cabinet Medal
   Presidency Relinquished
   Allegiance Medal
   Time Increases His Fame
   Commencement of Cabinet
   Double Head - Washington and Jackson
   Single Head - "   "

   Sizes (in sixteenths of an inch) are: 37, 25, 18, 16, 12, 10, 10.
   Prices are: $5.00, $3.00, $1.12, $0.75, $0.35, $0.25, $0.20.

   Jan notes: "Thanks for the info.  It is very helpful.  I think is
   interesting that no silver Indian Peace Medals are offered
   to the public on this list."

   The gold medals are:

   Time Increases His Fame
   Commencement of Cabinet
   Double Head - Washington and Jackson
   Single Head - "   "

   Sizes (same as silver): 16, 12, 10, 10
   Prices: $12.00, $6.25, $10, $10



   Regarding Dave Bower's desire for a "Dictionary of  Early
   American Bank Note Engravers and Printers", Wendell Wolka
   writes: "Enjoyed reading the E-Sylum #54 (as I always do) and
   noticed Dave Bowers' comments about a dictionary of early
   bank note companies and printers ... I seem to recall that
   Foster Wild Rice made such an effort when he published the
   "Antecedents of the American Bank Note Company" back
   in the 1950s (?).  Someplace in my library (we all have that
   problem, don't we!) I have a copy and it seems that he lists
   the years of operation of all of the different partnerships and
   name changes."

   [Great name: Foster Wild Rice.  Did he have an uncle
   named Ben?  -Editor]

   Joe Boling writes: "Is it possible that QDB does not know
   about Gene Hessler's "The Engraver's Line", a volume much
   like what he says he'd like to have?"


   Charles Davis  writes: "I devoted an entire page to the Pierce's
   Ormsby in Champa 1 where it sold to a mail bidder at $3,630."
   [NOTE: $3,300 plus a 10% buyer's fee is $3,630. -Editor]

   Michael J. Sullivan adds: You asked about the ownership history
   for the Ormsby appearing in the Heritage - CAA January auction.
   As Charlie Davis describes in Champa One (Nov. 1994),
   "obtained privately from Robert Wester."   While estimated at
   $5,000, it opened at $3,100 closing at $3,300 with Hugh Shull as
   the floor buyer.    So ...there is a piece of the story.  By the way,

   when Armand Champa acquired this second copy of Ormsby in
   his library, he sold his first Ormsby via a West Coast dealer to a
   St. Louis collector.   This occurred sometime around 1992."


   Regarding the "mile-and-a-half-long" URL for the Newman
   Museum article, Stephen Searle writes: "You may be interested
   in looking into  for your URLs in the E-Sylum.
   It is free and  it works.

   I made one for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch article on the
   Newman Numismatic Museum you provided.

   Keep up your excellent work!"

    [After plowing through dozens of junk emails telling me how
    to make certain things longer, it's a pleasant switch to read
    about making anything shorter.  I may use this in the future
    when the situation calls.   But readers are always advised to
    never count on any URL existing far into the future.  On the
    web, everything changes constantly.  So follow Mike Hodder's
    example - if you want to archive a referenced article for your
    files, print it out right away. Don't wait, or you may be
   disappointed later.  -Editor]


   David Sklow writes: "I have been hired by the American
   Numismatic Association. Sherry and I are very excited to be
   moving to Colorado Springs. I will be the new Numismatic

   [Congratulations to Dave, who is the former NBS
   Secretary-Treasurer and a longtime ANA history buff and
   volunteer ANA Historian.   His monthly columns in the
   Numismatist magazine are always interesting, and he'll make
   a fine researcher.  -Editor]


   Gar Travis writes: "I have picked up a very interesting hard
   cover book, copyright 1895, a privately printed 1st edition of
   "Silver and Gold or Both Sides of the Shield, with portraits
   (photographs) of leading Statesmen and Economists".  It was
   edited by Trumbull White (1868-1941), author of "The World's
   Columbian Exposition, " War in the East," "Pictorial History of
   Our War with Spain for Cuba's Freedom", "In the Shadow of
   Death: Martinique and the World's Great Disasters", "Our New
   Possessions", "Through Darkest America",  "Complete Story
   of the San Francisco Horror: Scenes of Death and Terror;
   also Eruption of Mt. Vesuvius and More Disasters;  San
   Francisco Earthquake of 1906", etc.

   The book is explained on the leading page as: A symposium of
   the views of all parties on the Currency Question as expressed
   by their leading advocates. Thoroughly expounding the doctrines
   of Free Silver, mono-metalism and bi-metalism, with all the
   arguments, pro. and con.  From the Pens of John Sherman, Wm.
   B. Allison, John G. Carlisle, Edward Atkinson, Wm. M. Stewart,
   W.J. Bryan, Wm. A. Peffer, Wm. H. Harvey, Benj. R. Tillman,
   and others.

    Trumbull White was the first editor of Redbook Magazine,
   founded in 1903, given that name because White said "red
   is the color of happiness".  He was editor of Ridgeway's
   "Everybody's Magazine" beginning with the October 1911
   issue in 1914 he was managing editor after which he
   departed the magazine. While a journalist, he was the first
   to advise the young Ernest Hemingway that the best writing
   comes from personal experience and during the Spanish
   American War he was a well known correspondent,
   popular author and historian.

   The book apparently was reprinted in 2001 "by" John
   Sherman and "edited" by Trumbull White
   ISBN: 0898756588 - Paperback."


   Jess W. Gaylor writes: "Here are a few references to the
   Josh Tatum Mystery, even one from an old E-Sylum.  Thanks
   for the great work."

   [These references are fine, but they don't answer the original
   question, which Pete Smith brought up in v3n19 and
   Bob Leonard revived in last week's issue:  Where was the
   story of Josh Tatum first published?   The earliest reference
   Bob found was in Lynn Glaser's 1968 "Counterfeiting in
   America"  book (pp. 224-6).  -Editor]


   This week's featured web site is the numismatic section of, a site devoted to preserving useful historical
   and other documents in electronic form.  The home page
   quotes Brother Bartholomew of Northumbria, A.D. 1159:
   "If any words are worth saving, it is these words."

   The site has three numismatic subsections, but the source
   of the texts are not well-documented.

       History of the US Mint
       Coins of the US Mint
       War Medals of the Confederacy

   The History of the Mint section includes

          Notes on the Early History of the Mint
              (From the Diary of Robert Morris)
          Establishment of the Philadelphia Mint
          Facsimile of Original Document of Congress that
              Establishes the Mint
          Payroll for Mint from 1795
          Extract From Rules and Regulations Adopted For the Mint,
January 1, 1825
          Enlargement of the Mint

  Wayne Homren
  Numismatic Bibliomania Society

  The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a
  non-profit organization promoting numismatic
  literature.   For more information please see
  our web site at
  There is a membership application available on
  the web site.  To join, print the application and
  return it with your check to the address printed
  on the application. For those without web access,
  write to W. David Perkins, NBS Secretary-Treasurer,
  P.O. Box 212, Mequon, WI  53092-0212.

  For Asylum mailing address changes and other
  membership questions, contact David at this email
  address: wdperki at

  To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum,
  just Reply to this message, or write to the Editor
  at this address: whomren at

   (To be removed from the E-Sylum mailing list
   send an email message with the word "Unsubscribe"
   in the body of the message to: esylum-request at

More information about the Esylum mailing list