The E-Sylum v6#38, September 22, 2003

whomren at whomren at
Mon Sep 22 19:57:15 PDT 2003

Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 6, Number 38, September 22, 2003:
an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
Copyright (c) 2003, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.


   This issue is a day late due to a problem which allowed
   incoming email but not outgoing, leaving me in an editorial
   comatose state.  All seems back to normal now.  Several of
   you wrote to inquire about your issue, and it's nice to know
   we're missed.   No one has been accidentally dropped, nor
   has a hurricane flattened the E-Sylum War Room or cut the
   power.  All is well.  Thanks for your concern and patience.


   Col. Bill Murray writes: "Perhaps NBS members and readers
   of The E-Sylum might be interested in knowing two new, well
   relatively new, numismatic words made it into the fifth edition
   of the Oxford English Dictionary.  Exonumia (but not exonomist),
   and scripophily (but not syngrapics nor lignadenarist).  We
   need to promote our hobby more, it appears.

   Keep up the good work, Wayne.  The E-Sylum continues to
   inform and titlliate.  Also, congratulations to all the newly elected

  and re-elected NBS Board members.  Thanks for serving."


   From the Press Release: "George Frederick Kolbe/Fine
   Numismatic Books will conduct their 92nd auction sale of
   rare and important numismatic literature on Thursday,
   November 13, 2003. The sale features 1635 lots covering
   a wide range of numismatic topics.  Featured is the interesting
   and notable library of a “Sage Old Roman,” selections from
   The Money Tree archives, and material from over fifty other
   consignors.  The firm’s next sale will not be held until June 1,
   2004 when, in association with Stack’s, George Frederick
   Kolbe will conduct the first public auction of the superb
   American numismatic library formed with dedication and
   great care by John J. Ford, Jr. over many years.

   A few November 13th sale highlights follow: a collection of
   175 bound Sotheby auction sale catalogues, 1830-1900,
   assembled by the renowned British coin collector Henry Platt
   Hall; an 1879 catalogue of Berlin coin dealer Adolph Weyl
   containing the previously unreported, earliest European
   appearance of an 1804 silver dollar at auction; many early
   Yeoman “Red Books,” including a complete set; an unbound
   set of “The Numismatist,” 1894-2002; classic works on
   ancient Greek and Roman coins; a complete set of B. Max
   Mehl auction sale catalogues, also very fine deluxe
   leatherbound copies of the Dunham and Morse, Faelton &
   Todd sales; an important selection of works on Napoleonic
   and other medals; legal documents and correspondence
   pertaining to the Roy E. Naftzger, Jr. versus American
   Numismatic Society litigation concerning the Clapp/Sheldon
   large cent controversy; important Walter Breen
   correspondence; rare works on Serbian numismatics;
   important antiquarian numismatic books dating from 1557;
   an original copy of Miles’ “The Numismatic History of Rayy,”
   along with many other important works on foreign coins and
   medals; the paper money archives of Dr. John A. Muscalus;

   The sale may be viewed at Copies of the
   printed catalogue are available for $15.00.

   The firm has already started work on the public auction sale
   of the John J. Ford, Jr. Library. To be held in association with
   Stack’s, this landmark sale will take place on Tuesday, June 1,
   2004...  Periodic reports about the many rare and interesting
   things that will be in the sale will appear in the E-sylum, weekly
   electronic newsletter of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
   Those interested in subscribing, free of charge, are invited to
   visit the society’s web site:  Regular
   updates will also be posted on the firm’s web site:

   [Many thanks for George for keeping us up to date and for
   promoting NBS and The E-Sylum via his press release.
   The first of his Ford Library updates follows.  -Editor]


   George Kolbe writes: "This past week, cataloguing began
   on the John J. Ford, Jr. Library. Slowly. Delightful surprises
   abound.   Among items catalogued from several cartons
   randomly unpacked are the following:

   F. C. C. Boyd's deluxe leatherbound 1941 Dunham sale
   catalogue, the finest example we recall ever having encountered.

   Three leatherbound volumes of Bureau of Engraving and
   Printing vignettes, any one of which would be the finest,
   condition-wise, compared to any previously encountered.
   Two are official productions, issued circa 1876, each with
   nearly 150 superb engravings. The third is a monumental
   volume, containing over 200 BEP engravings assembled
   privately by Joseph K. Edgerton,who served in Congress
   from 1863 to 1865 and presumably obtained them as
   perquisites of office.

   Several unique Chapman brothers bid books. Among them:
   Colin E. King with plates; Boeing-Bridgman with plates; and
   McCoye with a handwritten note stating that “The plates for
   this catalogue proved failures and were not issued but were all

   S. H. Chapman's priced and named Stickney sale catalogue
   with superb plates no doubt handpicked by the photographer,
   i.e., S. H. himself.

   A fine example in the original printed card covers, with plates,
   of the 1914 Foster Lardner sale of large cents, along with a
   flyer promoting Lardner's skills as a magician and lecturer, and
   a superb photograph of Lardner.

   S. H. Chapman’s plated, priced and named 1915 Granberg
   Sale, perhaps the finest of the four or five plated examples
   that have come to market in the past quarter century.

   A superb example of the 1925 W. W. C. Wilson sale with
   the full complement of plates. Ex F. C. C. Boyd and perhaps
   Henry Chapman, whose lengthy invoice for the sale - including
   $15.00 for a plated copy of the catalogue - is included. Also
   catalogued were priced and named copies of the second and
   third Wilson sales.

   David Proskey's 1885 bid book of the Thian sale of Confederate
   paper money.

   Quite a start. Will future reports be as exciting?  I do not know.
   Stay tuned."


   Fred Lake of Lake Books writes: "The prices realized list for
   our sale #70 which closed on September 16, 2003 is now
   available for viewing on our web site at:

   When you reach that web page please click on the year 2003
   (or scroll down) and you will see the two options for opening
   the PRL (either PDF format or Word format).

   Many thanks to our bidders and please note that our next
   sale will be held on November 18, 2003 and features
   selections from the library of the late Stuart Hodge plus Part
   Two of the Dr. William Hopkins library."


   Gregg Silvis writes: "I'm trying to track down an item for
   research-related purposes:  I'm looking for the August,
   1928 issue of the Guttag Brothers Coin Bulletin.  The
   ANA Library has only the June, 1928 issue, which is
   volume 6, number 4.  The ANS Library has only 1928
   volume 6, number 1.  Any information on the whereabouts
   of a copy of the August issue would be greatly appreciated.
   I can be contacted at gregg at  Thanks!"


   Bob Lyall reminds us that "Not only the Swedes but
   a majority of the British population do not want to join
   the Euro and throw away independence of financial

   Bill Swoger writes: "A note about another "holdout":
   Great Britain didn't accept the "new" calendar until
   1752.  Therefore, 1752 was the shortest year in
   U.S. history."


   Allan Davisson writes: "Another plagiarism note: Much
   of the material in the Bell books on tokens ("Conders")
   was taken, without acknowledgment, from Saumuel's
   series of articles in The Bazaar Exchange and Mart published
   from 1880-1889."


   Len Augsburger writes: "I did see an episode of "History's
   Mysteries" while channel surfing.  On the show I watched, a
   family in the deep south who owned a house wanted to check
   out some oral history which indicated a black man had owned
   the same home in the 19th century.  They wondered how that
   could have been.  The show visited 3 or 4 cities, and traced
   the individual in question, a free black as it turned out.  They
   were able to come up with some detail of the man's
   successful business, his family, and verified the story.  The used
   local professors and all the other usual historical resources (city
   directories, census data, state and local archives and historical
   societies, etc.)."

   Gar Travis writes: "A much better "view" than Antiques Road
   Show - the history sleuth's tell the truth to would be keepers
   of history - was the pocket watch a gift from Mark Twain -
   No!... and I enjoyed seeing the sleuth share the truth with the
   watch's keeper.

   We could use them on the newly "discovered" first dollar.
   My bet is that it is a later restrike like the 1804's - but for a
   collector later in the 19th century."


   Alan Luedeking writes: "Regarding Mr. Hulse's request
   concerning availability of a translation to English of the
   Calicó-Trigo catalogue "Monedas Españolas desde Felipe IV
   a Isabel II - 1621 a 1868" , I am not aware of any such
   translation, however, I'd be pleased to help him translate
   anything he wants to/from Spanish/English, providing it's not
   the whole book!  What puzzles me though, is Mr. Hulse's
   asking specifically about the third edition (1979) of this work:
   each subsequent edition expanded this excellent reference a
   little further, both forwards and backwards in time, to where
   the current (9th) edition now covers the whole enchilada
   from Ferdinand & Isabella to 1998 in one large volume.
   Why that old edition Mr Hulse??"


   Regarding the request for help identifying people appearing in
   the 1909 American Numismatic Association photo, David
   Sklow, ANA Historian adds: "Mrs. Zerbe's name was Bessie,
   that was Farran's first wife -- he married her in 1908 and
   married Gertrude in 1932.  Mrs. Waldo Moore's name was

   Karl Moulton  writes: "In response to additional names for the
   1909 ANA photograph, here are a few:

   Number 1 is Paul Napoleon Breton, who earlier that day had
   tried to disrupt the business meeting.

   Number 2 is Judge William A  Ashbrook, who was elected to
   the board of governors.

   Number 3, the taller gentleman with the gray hair is most likely
   William Forrester Dunham, also elected to the board that year.

   Number 4 may be J. de Lagerberg, board member.

   Number 5 may be M. Belanger or M. Tessier.

   Number 6, the older gentleman with the gray beard may be one
   of the names  mentioned in number 5.  One of the other two
   may be Mr. Mousseau or Mr. Richards,  both were newspaper
   reporters covering the convention.  One of these reporters is
   standing in front of the two ladies in the back row on the far right
   side.   The third reporter, of "La Patrie", a French daily, was Mr.
   Edmond Chasse and his young wife of a few weeks.  They are
   in the back row to the left of  Ben Green.

   Number 7 possibly Henry Chapman's wife, as she is sitting next
   to Henry in  the "official" convention photograph described below.

   This photograph is just one of several taken at the convention.
   As it was taken on a separate outing early in the proceedings on
   Tuesday August 10, I  doubt that it is the official convention
   photograph, even though it is the one published in the September/
   October issue of The Numismatist, p. 259.  A more believable
   "official" convention photograph was taken on Thursday, August
   12 in front of the Cartier Normal School and was published in
   Mehl's Numismatic Monthly, September 1909, p. 131."


   David Fanning forwarded this question from Lisa Mao,
   Segment Producer, Indigo Films: "I had contacted you in
   the spring regarding Ft. Knox when we were producing a
   show on the gold depository.

   Currently I am doing research on paper money and am looking
   for an expert who can talk about its "shelf life".  Do numismatists
   deal only with coins or do they also take an interest in paper
   money?  I am interested in contacting someone who can tell me
   how long paper currency can last, and under what conditions?
   For example, if money is buried in the ground for 50 years, will
   it still be intact or will it have disintegrated?

   Thank you so much for your time and I look forward to your

   [Does anyone have some answers?  We'll forward them to
    Ms. Mao.  Meanwhile, anyone wishing to experiment is
    invited to deposit any sum of paper money in a hole I'll dig
    in my back yard, free of charge.  -Editor]


   Regarding our earlier Topic of the Week, Bob Fritsch
   writes: "I did not see many replies to this particular topic.
   Q. David Bowers' book on the S.S. Central America
   Treasure certainly needs special handling to prevent personal
   injury.  Several years ago I acquired a music stand from a
   music store that was going out of business.  Not one of those
   flimsy fold-up things, but a good heavy chunk of bent metal.
   Some call it a Concert Stand.  It is not only handy as a
   portable lectern, but is great to hold the Standard Catalog of
   World Coins (for example) beside my work table while
   cataloging those collections.  It has held the aforementioned
   SS CA book while I comfortably recline on the couch happily
   absorbing the material.  I paid about $30 for mine but imagine
   the price has gone up as it has for everything else."


   In response to my query about Rene Laflamme's "reversible
   banknotes,"  Alan Roy writes: "I had bid on one at a Jeffrey
   Hoare Auction in 1997.  It was a $1 note that went for $21
   Canadian plus 10% commission.  There is a picture in the
   catalog if anybody is interested in a scan."


   Alan Luedeking writes: "Regarding Bob Merchant's query
   regarding Haitian coinage sales in E-Sylum v6#36, the 1998
   Spink sale in question is the Spink America (New York) sale
   of 1 December 1998.  It is indeed an important sale for Haiti.
   I can also recommend the Mangones Collection Sale by
   Harmer Rooke, New York, 8 April 1976, as one of the most
   important sales ever for Haiti.  Two other good sales are
   Spink London #87, 9 October 1991, important for Emilio
   Ortiz's West Indies material, which included some good Haiti,
   and Adolph Weyl's Auction Sale No. 80 (Berlin) of 4-6
   January 1887, containing "...Eine Nahezu Komplette
   Sammlung der Insel Haïti."


   In response to a recent note on the Colonial Numismatics
   email group declaring that "One can only have so many books
   in one's library...",  Dan Friedus replied: "I keep trying to find
   the upper limit but have not discovered it yet.  My bookshelves
   are long since full but somehow there's always another corner
   into which I can cram a book."

   Ray Williams added: "I know what you mean about the size
   of libraries.  Attached is a picture of Diane's china cabinets
   (2 of three - the third is also filled with books).  Did I marry
   well, or what!!!   If there were a contest for "Numismatist's
   Wife of the Year..."


   [Not numismatic, but E-Sylum readers include quite a
   few word mavens, so I thought I'd pass this along.

   David Cassell writes: "Aoccdrnig to a rscheearch at
   Cmabrigde Uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer in waht oredr the
   ltteers in a wrod are, the olny iprmoetnt tihng is taht the frist
   and lsat ltteer be at the rghit pclae.  The rset can be a total
   mses and you can sitll raed it wouthit porbelm. Tihs is
   bcuseae the huamn mnid deos nt raed ervey lteter by istlef,
   but the wrod as a wlohe."


   This week's featured web page was mentioned on the
   Colonial Numismatics email list by E-Sylum subscriber Ray
   Turcotte. It's a page that is devoted to coin maker Abel
   Buell and it includes good images of his counterstamp.

  Wayne Homren
  Numismatic Bibliomania Society

  The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a
  non-profit organization promoting numismatic
  literature.   For more information please see
  our web site at
  There is a membership application available on
  the web site.  To join, print the application and
  return it with your check to the address printed
  on the application. For those without web access,
  write to W. David Perkins, NBS Secretary-Treasurer,
  P.O. Box 212, Mequon, WI  53092-0212.

  For Asylum mailing address changes and other
  membership questions, contact David at this email
  address: wdperki at

  To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum,
  just Reply to this message, or write to the Editor
  at this address: whomren at

   (To be removed from the E-Sylum mailing list
   send an email message with the word "Unsubscribe"
   in the body of the message to: esylum-request at

More information about the Esylum mailing list