The E-Sylum v19n18 May 1, 2016

The E-Sylum esylum at
Sun May 1 19:16:34 PDT 2016

The E-Sylum
  An electronic publication of
  The Numismatic Bibliomania Society

Volume 19, Number 18, May 1, 2016

Click here to read this issue on the web

Click here to access the complete archive

To comment or submit articles, reply to whomren at


New subscribers this week include: 
Ryan Drake, courtesy of Tom Sheehan,
David Heinrich of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association, and Bill Bierly.
Welcome aboard! We now have 1,969 subscribers.

Welcome to our newest advertiser, numismatic literature dealer Douglas Saville. 
This week we open with two new books, two book reviews, a video, and an update on the Newman Numismatic Portal.

Other topics this week include U.S. Proof Set mailing boxes,  the origin of the dollar sign,  the Civil War Token Journal, dealer Victor England, numismatics at the Vatican Library, and Fitter Families medals.

To learn more about "Short rolls" of Statehood Quarters, the Joshua Coin, cob coinage, Pirate Libraries, C.W. Franklin's Numismatic Blue Book, the Scher Collection of medals, the coin cabinet of the Vatican Library and anthropodermic bibliopegy, read on. Have a great week, everyone!

Wayne Homren 
Editor, The E-Sylum



Dennis Tucker of Whitman Publishing forwarded this announcement of the new edition of Mega Red, Whitman's Guide Book of United States Coins, Deluxe Edition.

The second edition of Whitman Publishing’s Guide Book of United States Coins, Deluxe Edition, popularly known as MEGA RED, debuted at the Whitman Baltimore Coin and Collectibles Expo on March 31, 2016. Larger than the regular-edition Red Book, and with more pages, Mega Red retails for $49.95. It can be ordered online (including at and is available from booksellers and hobby shops nationwide. American Numismatic Association members receive a 10% discount off all purchases from Whitman, since the publisher is the Official Supplier of the ANA.

Advertised as the “biggest, most useful Red Book ever,” Mega Red measures 7 x 10 inches and has 1,504 pages. The larger size and increased page count combined make it five times bigger than the regular-edition Red Book. It prices 8,297 items in up to 13 grades each, with 47,000 individual values and 15,800 auction records covering circulated, Mint State, and Proof coinage. The book is illustrated with 5,800 images.

Like the first edition, the second edition of Mega Red covers American coinage from New England colonial times to the modern day—half cents through $20 gold double eagles, plus bullion, commemoratives, Proof and Mint sets, significant tokens and medals, error coins, and other numismatic collectibles. It follows the basic structure of the regular-edition Red Book, but each chapter is dramatically expanded with more grades and prices, more historical information, more die varieties, detailed grading instructions with enlarged full-color illustrations, specialized advice on strike characteristics and other technical details, market analysis, and valuable guidance on collecting and investing in rare coins.

The book’s Senior Editor is Kenneth Bressett, Valuations Editor is Jeff Garrett, and Research Editor is Q. David Bowers. A 57-page introduction, “The Story of American Money,” is based on the work of the late Dr. Richard Doty, senior curator of the National Numismatic Collection at the Smithsonian.

Each year, the new Mega Red features an in-depth focus on one or more coin series. The first edition included a special 364-page section on copper half cents and large cents written by Q. David Bowers, with images, history, diagnostics, and pricing for 832 die varieties, 1793–1857.

The second edition includes a detailed 330-page section on Flying Eagle, Indian Head, and Lincoln cents, covering 607 dates and varieties, plus patterns, counterstamps, errors, and other specialized topics.

For federal coins, detailed charts show each mintage; a summary of certified population data; average national retail prices in grades ranging from About Good to high Mint State and Proof; and three or more recent auction records for most coins. Enlarged close-ups of die varieties provide visual guidance. Extensive chart notes give the back stories and additional details on significant coins.

“We trademarked the name Mega Red when more and more collectors started referring to the Deluxe Edition by its nickname,” said Whitman publisher Dennis Tucker. “The first edition created a lot of excitement in the hobby community, and the second edition is even more exciting because its expanded feature covers three of the most popular coin series, the small cents of 1856 to date. That feature alone is the size of a normal book. Plus the second edition is full of updates, new essays, additional content, and more illustrations.”

In the second edition, coverage of pre-federal coins has been increased to include foreign coins that circulated in the British North American colonies: Spanish-American cob coinage of the 1500s to 1770s, Pillar coins of the 1700s, Bust coins of the 1770s to early 1820s, and various Dutch, French, and British copper and silver coin of the 1600s to early 1800s. “European coins of this era are so fundamental to American numismatics that every collection should include at least a sampling,” said Senior Editor Kenneth Bressett. The pre-federal chapters comprise 60 pages illustrated with 407 photographs, historical information, and pricing in multiple grades.

Recurring appendices include illustrated essays on misstrikes and error coins; rare and collectible Red Books and Blue Books; bullion values of common-date silver and gold coins; the top 250 coin prices realized at auction; and the ANA grading standards for U.S. coins.

New to the second edition are appendices on

         So-Called Dollars,

         Scouting and numismatics,

         the American Arts gold medallions of 1980 to 1984,

         modern U.S. Mint gold and silver medals,

         investing in modern gold and silver bullion,

         building a registry set, with insight from PCGS and NGC,

         determining coin prices and values,

         nationwide and specialized coin clubs and groups,

         how to get a new die variety into the Red Book, and

         collecting old and new numismatic literature.

Mega Red, 2nd edition (A Guide Book of United States Coins, Deluxe Edition)
ISBN 0794843921
Softcover, 7 x 10 inches
1,504 pages
Full color
Retail $49.95 U.S.        

For more information, or to order, see: 

2017 Official Red Book of United States Coins - Deluxe Edition




 Didn’t win the Mega Millions drawing?  
You can still daydream about buried, hoarded, forgotten, and rediscovered coins. Q. David Bowers is back to delight us with hundreds of tales of Lost and Found Coin Treasures and Hoards. Hardcover, 480 pages, full color. Get your copy today for $39.95
, or call 1-800-546-2995.


A new edition of the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Modern Issues has been published by Krause Publications.  Here's the info from their web site.

Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Modern Issues, 22nd Edition
By Maggie Judkins
Format: Paperback

Utilizing a worldwide network of numismatics experts, the 22nd edition of the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Modern Issues provides the most comprehensive and complete reference to world bank notes issued since 1961.

This industry-leading catalog features:

22,000 variety listings of world bank notes

13,750 illustrations for easy identification of notes and signature varieties

Bank note values in two popularly available conditions

Country signature charts for specific and accurate variety identification

Hundreds of new bank note issues

With contributions from an international team of collectors, dealers, researches and national bank officials working to ensure accuracy, the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Modern Issues is the most informed and all-encompassing resource on the market for the proper identification, description and valuation of modern world bank notes.

SKU	S9926
Author/Speaker/Editor	Maggie Judkins
Format	Paperback
ISBN 13	9781440246562
Number Of Pages	1168

For more infornation, or to order, see: 

Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Modern Issues, 22nd Edition




Last week I asked if anyone was familiar with books mentioned on the Biblioteca Numismatica blog. Two readers offered some information for us. Thanks!

David Pickup writes:

I have a copy of Las Monedas Reselladas de Felipe II y Felipe IV.
 It is quite a slim paperback catalogue of the copper coins in the Seventeenth Century which were countermarked up and down  in value as inflation rose and fell. It is very comprehensive (as far as I can tell) and well-illustrated. It is easy to understand – if you read Spanish!
 I bought my copy on holiday in Barcelona at the shop of a dealer in Plaza del Angel.

 American colonists who made the transition
from ps to the new sign.  (This is apparently also why we write $1
instead of 1$; it mimics the British use of the pound sign.)  So,
while it did not originally refer to the U.S. dollar, the symbol
does legitimately claim its origins in that country.

To read the complete article, see: 

Origin of the dollar sign


I answered my own question by checking the E-Sylum archives - Eric Newman was well aware of this source when writing his 1993 paper, "The Dollar $ign: Its Written and Printed Origins"   Eric added material Cajori did not know about, and corrected things other people had written in their zeal to annoint other "creators" of the symbol.

To read the earlier E-Sylum articles, see: 










Maureen Levine submitted these selections from the upcoming Heritage internet-only sale of items from the Eric P. Newman collection. Thanks!  The sale closes May 4, 2016, so get your bids in.

If you haven’t yet perused the fascinating items in this sale, there is still a little
time left. A few of the many highlights are listed below.

 Lot 86299: Vermont 40 Shillings Note 
This bold Vermont 40 shillings might well be viewed as a “Fourteenth Colony”
note to typeset collectors.

State of Vermont February 1781 40 Shillings Fr. VT-7. 
The frail paper, brief period of issue and the fact that only eight denominations were emitted contribute to their rarity. Because many collectors desire an example for a general typeset, or to add in with their "Thirteen Colonies" sets, the existing 150 or so known of all denominations tends to be rather spread out. Only the major cabinets, such as the Newman Collection, have had one or more denominations. Even F.C.C. Boyd did not have a complete eight denomination set. 

The series was printed by Judah Spooner and Timothy Green III on very thin, fragile paper that cracked quickly and disintegrated over time. The notes were used for a year, then their legal tender status was revoked; but they continued to be used for paying taxes and were destroyed at the time of payment. The face shows fancy side borders and top border cut. At the lower left is a seal with the motto VERMONT CALLS FOR JUSTICE. The back shows a diamond pattern rectangle forming a cartouche with the imprint and counterfeit warning inside. 

To read the complete lot description, see:

 Lot 86416: D. V. Henry Confederate States Sutler 
Sutler issues are always of great interest, and this gallantly titled Confederate
Sutler of First Arkansas Mounted Rifles 10 cents note is likely unique.

Lewisburg, AR - D. V. Henry Confederate States Sutler of First Arkansas Mounted Rifles 10 Cents Feb. 7, 1862 Rothert 366-1, Keller AR-SA010.

This historic and gallantly titled sutler note is likely unique. Plated in Rothert and Keller, and the missing ten percent of the right end of the note does not diminish its importance. Printed on white paper. Texts and titles are in the right center. The left end panel shows a perpendicular train in oval. Payable in "...[Camp] Bragg or Lewisburg." Most of the signature is visible. 

The First was originally formed in Little Rock in June 16, 1861 and was composed of companies A-K. They fought in important, early Western Theatre engagements such as Wilson's Creek, and later in the year were sent to the Indian Territory to engage pro-Union Cherokees. Early in 1862 they were involved in the Battle of Pea Ridge directed by the officers of the Army of the West. The First Arkansas Mounted Rifles was not a Confederate Cavalry unit for long, as they were dismounted by the middle of 1862. There was tremendous reorganization of Confederate forces at that time and Arkansas enlistments were adjusted as well. They fought through the War and eventually surrendered in North Carolina in April 1865 as part of the Army of Tennessee. 

To read the complete lot description, see:


 Lot 86701: St. Joseph, LA - Parish of Tensas $5 April 4, 1862 
In Louisiana, counties are called Parishes. This Parish of Tensas $5 is a choice
example with both color and style.

St. Joseph, LA - Parish of Tensas $5 April 4, 1862. PCGS About New 53PPQ.

A Choice example from this scarcer parish note series. Distinctively printed on white paper in brown ink. Like other denominations from the series, it shows a seated allegorical female at the center. At the far left is a Native American princess and kneeling Agriculture. At the far right is a clipper ship. Red protector numerals flank the center vignette, and FIVE DOLLARS is across the bottom center. 

To read the complete lot description, see:

 Lot 86751: Nantucket, MA - Nantucket Bank $3 May 10, 1806
This intriguing Nantucket Bank $3, though a well made false note, is the plate
note in The Early Paper Money of America.

Nantucket, MA - Nantucket Bank $3 May 10, 1806 Contemporary Counterfeit MA-855 C14, Newman Page 220. 

A very scarce type listed in The Early Paper Money of America (Fifth Edition), by Eric P. Newman on page 220, where it is the plate note. The early bank was founded in 1795, but had its affairs settled by 1816. We have never encountered a genuine note or a proof from the bank. This type is one of the most intriguing from the early Obsolete note-issuing period. 

This note shows a perpendicular, spouting whale on which is a downward-facing "3" balanced by the upward facing "3" at the right end. The end panel at left shows BANK, which looks like it was fashioned from rope. Counters with the number, text, and Roman numerals are on differently shaped, shaded backgrounds. Texts and obligations are across. "Pen Cancelled" with "Tape Repaired Edge Tears." However, this is an iconic type, and the Newman plate note stature adds to its desirability. An essential member of this early banking period's notes.

To read the complete lot description, see:

 Lot 87246: Madison, WI - Bank of Wisconsin $1
Rare Wisonsin proofs from the collection often have relevant vignettes. The
Juneau portrait (founder of Milwaukee), patriotic allegory, and vivid color form
powerful combination.

Madison, WI - Bank of Wisconsin $1 18__ WI-400 G2a. 

The riveting Bank of Wisconsin vermillion color title series was engraved and printed by Toppan, Carpenter & Co., New York & Philadelphia.

The central vignette shows a Continental soldier, peering down at the British forces, as his companion loads another rifle. At the lower left is a rarely seen portrait of Solomon Juneau, the founder of Milwaukee. The vermillion title arcs over the top and there is a subtle ONE protector across each signature. Hole Punch Cancelled through the India paper and the card. Like all three denominations from this series, it is very beautiful. 

To read the complete lot description, see:

 Lot 87488: $5 1934A Hawaii Federal Reserve Note
This Gem HAWAII $5 emergency note evokes the nation’s peril during World
War II.

Fr. 2302 $5 1934A Hawaii Federal Reserve Note

Gem Hawaii $5 FRNs are never in large supply. This gorgeous note is sure to garner plenty of attention as the margins are large, the paper quality is excellent, and the colors are quite vivid.

To read the complete lot description, see:

 The sale closes Wednesday May 4, 2016 starting at 10:00 AM CDT. To place
bids, please visit

 SELECTIONS FROM THE JOHN HUFFMAN LIBRARY: Browse and Shop Approximately 3,000 Numismatic Books from the Respected Library
 of John Huffman—All Books Recently Discounted 40%. Click here or go to click on “All Subjects” and select “John Huffman Collection”


Here's how news bounces around the world these days.  An ABC News affiliate in Houston, TX did a story about an eighth grade girl who got in trouble for spending a supposed counterfeit bill at school.  Across the pond the Daily Mail grabs screen captures from the video, slaps on a sensational headline and publishes its own story.  E-Sylum subscriber Dick Hanscom in Alaska sees the story and forwards it to me.  And now you guys are about to read it.

I generally avoid publishing counterfeiting stories because they're so common and all tell pretty much the same story.  This one is different and deserves the sensational treatment to rebuke the incompetence of the local school officials.

When you think of felony forgery your thoughts might turn to Al Capone or Bonnie and Clyde shooting it out with the Texas Rangers.

Not for some local school cops. For one day, public enemy number one when it came to forgery was 13-year-old eighth grader Danesiah Neal at Fort Bend Independent School District's Christa McAuliffe Middle School.

Now 14, Daneisha was hoping to eat that day's lunch of chicken tenders with her classmates using a $2 bill given to her by her grandmother when she was stopped by the long arm of the law.

"I went to the lunch line and they said my $2 bill was fake," Danesiah told Ted Oberg Investigates. "They gave it to the police. Then they sent me to the police office. A police officer said I could be in big trouble."

Not just big trouble. Third-degree felony trouble.

School officials called Daneisha's grandmother Sharon Kay Joseph.

The officials asked, "'Did you give Danesiah a $2 bill for lunch?' He told me it was fake," she said.

Then the Fort Bend ISD police investigated the $2 bill with the vigor of an episode of Dragnet...

Next stop -- and these are just the facts -- the cop went to a bank to examine the bill.

Finally, the mystery was solved: The $2 bill wasn't a fake at all. It was real.

The bill so old, dating back to 1953, the school's counterfeit pen didn't work on it.

"He brought me my two dollar bill back," Joseph said. He didn't apologize. He should have and the school should have because they pulled Danesiah out of lunch and she didn't eat lunch that day because they took her money."

Joseph said something needs to change so kids don't have felonies looming over their heads for minor crimes -- or actions that aren't even crimes at all.

"It was very outrageous for them to do it," she said. "There was no need for police involvement. They're charging kids like they're adults now."

Now, as numismatists you and I all know what a two-dollar bill is and what they look like.  And those school and police officials are probably younger and had never seen one before.  But calling the police seems bonkers.  At least the cops did the right thing by first confirming with a knowledgeable third party at a local bank.  So why couldn't school officials do the same before causing such a disruption?  The poor girl didn't deserve that treatment; she deserves an apology.

To read the complete articles, see: 



Eighth grader sparks counterfeit investigation after she tried to pay for her lunch with a REAL $2 bill from her grandmother



If this were April 1st rather than May 1st I'd be awfully suspect of this story, but quite unfortunately, it's true.
An April 26, 2016 "Object of Intrigue" article in the Atlas Obscura blog discussed the medals issued by the American Eugenics Society for their "Fitter Families" contest, where people were basically judged alongside hogs and champion rutabegas at county fairs.

On August 17, 1920, the Topeka Daily Capital reported an exciting development: a new class of competition had been added to the livestock judging categories at the Kansas Free Fair. Class 2.603, part of the Division 203, “Human Stock,” allowed families to submit themselves for judging by the fair's eugenics department. If they were deemed the most pleasing specimens at the fair, they would win the title of “Fitter Family.”

Though the category was new, the judging of humans according to the principles of eugenics wasn’t a novel concept in 1920. For at least a decade, state fairs across America had been holding “Better Baby” competitions, in which infants were examined, measured, compared to growth charts, and awarded trophies for good health and genetic superiority. University of Michigan history professor Martin S. Pernick writes that such contests “rivaled livestock breeding and hybrid corn exhibits in popularity.”

Fitter Family competitions, which spread from Kansas across America during the 1920s, were an extension of the Better Babies idea. The advantage of examining older children and adults was that, unlike babies, these specimens could talk back. They also had more life experience for judges to draw upon when making their evaluations.

For every family, representatives from the Eugenics Society of the United States of America would fill out the Fitter Families Examination form. The required details for each family member included their date and place of birth, any serious illnesses, their education, occupation, “physical, mental or temperamental defects,” and “special talents, gifts, tastes, or superior qualities.”

The whole judging process lasted about three-and-a-half hours, and took place in the fair's Eugenics Building. Tacked onto the walls were posters declaring that within three generations, careful breeding could eliminate "unfit human traits" such as feeblemindedness, criminality, pauperism, and epilepsy. 

Anyone scoring a B+ or better was given a bronze medal bearing the phrase “Yea, I have a goodly heritage.” This phrase was swiped from Psalm 16:6—the full sentence is, “The lines are fallen unto me in pleasant places; yea, I have a goodly heritage.”

To read the complete article, see: 

Here Are the Medals Given to Eugenically Healthy Humans in the 1920s


On the internet you'll find quite a bit of information on Eugenics and its disasterous consequences worldwide.
It's just bizarre to think of today.

To read the complete article, see: 

The Horrifying American Roots of Nazi Eugenics


So how would they have ranked my family?  "The large male is rather doughy and smells funny.  Minus 10 points"

Anyway, the closest numismatic connection we've discussed so far were Laura Gardin Fraser's "Better Baby" medals.

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: 


OVER 500 NUMISMATIC TITLES: Wizard Coin Supply has over 500 numismatic titles in stock, competitively discounted, and
available for immediate shipment. See our selection at


Wednesday, May 1, 2016 started out like nearly every workday, except that a packed bag was stored on the back of my car.  After working a little over half a day I ducked out early to head for Dulles airport.  Destination: Chicago.

I'd been invited to participate in the Numismatic Editor's Forum at the Central States Numismatic Society show.  I was looking forward to it.  I never really set out to become an editor, I just fell into it as a part-time task when I started The E-Sylum.  it was too much fun, so I just never quit.

After parking my car and shuttling to the terminal I found a Men's Room and entered a handicapped stall to change into some casual clothes.  It had one of those automatic toilets, so every time I moved an elbow or knee the toilet flushed.  When I emerged the room was deserted - they may have hightailed it, understandably thinking I was an Ebola victim fresh off a flight from Ghana.

My United flight was blissfully uneventful until our landing in Chicago.  BAM!  While we were all still digesting what we'd heard and felt, there was another BAM!  It was our landing gear hitting hard.  But all was well, thankfully.

I caught a cab to the Renaissance Schaumburg Convention Center hotel and checked into my room.  The staff was very friendly and helpful, and my room was great.  Laid out like a Grand Hyatt, the hotel had a huge central atrium.

After unpacking some things I went downstairs looking for some casual snack food in the bar.  I quickly ran into Pete Smith, who was just finishing a meal.  
We then grabbed seats at the end of the bar to catch up.

I passed on the Fried Bologna sandwich, which sounded like a heart attack waiting to happen.  I ordered the tacos, but I thought they tasted horrible.  The bartender let me reorder, and I got a small pizza this time.  Not so healthy either, but at least what I ate of it was tasty.

Topics with Pete included families and work, and Pete's newest project.  He'd codenamed it project G.R.O.S.S., which stands for "Getting Rid of Some Stuff".  God bless him.  We collectors can accumulate inordinate amounts of stuff, especially bibliophiles.  We talked about venues and strategies for selling and donating coins and numismatic literature.

I was nursing a single-malt scotch through all of this, and it was good.  Usually the only drinks I have in the course of a month are some wine at our Nummis Nova social group dinners.

Eventually it was time to split up; I paid my tab and headed to my room, where I ironed a shirt and watched the Robert Redford baseball movie The Natural on TV.  It was a nice evening away from working on The E-Sylum.

But I didn't slack off for long - I got up at 5:30 Thursday morning and worked on articles from Harvey Stack, Robert Hoge and others.  I went downstairs for breakfast and ordered the buffet.  it was a good choice.  There was a great stock of fresh hot and cold food.  I'm usually a cereal eater but I indulged with some good sausage, crisp bacon and delicious roasted potatoes.  Cooked with onions and peppers, they were quite tasty, although I came to realize that they weren't potatoes so much as a butter delivery mechanism - not a good everyday choice.  But this was one of the best hotel breakfasts I'd ever had. 

Back up at my room I got back to work on The E-Sylum and also made a phone call to sort out a credit card matter for my wife.  At 9:30 I showered and got dressed, and by 10 was heading over to the convention center side of the complex.

 Editor's Forum 

I quickly found the room where the Editors Forum would be held, and Beth Deisher was already there.  We talked a while about our preparations and discussion topics, as well as the Newman Numismatic Portal.  Steve Roach soon arrived and joined us.

I excused myself to go get a drink of water and soon ran into our fourth panelist, David Harper of Numismatic News, and led him back to the Forum room.  Attendees were already getting seated, and David Lisot was setting up 
his video equipment.

While we were waiting to start I briefly spoke with Gerry Tebben, Bruce Perdue and David Lisot.  After Gerry kicked things off Beth talked from a PowerPoint deck she'd prepared, giving some very good advice on understanding your audience, soliciting articles, and easy-to-use newsletter templates.

In my own opening remarks I emphasized that the Editor's task doesn't have to be a lonely one.  I get by every day with a little help from my friends, and I gave this example.  A couple weeks ago, I excerpted John Kraljevich's Introduction to the Stack's Bowers Pogue Four catalog, where he noted how useful the Newman Numismatic Portal was to his work as a cataloguer.

I remembered something pertinent that Joel Orosz once said to me about the Portal, and I dashed off a note asking if he would send me a few sentences for an upcoming issue (that's step 1).  He did.  Now for step 2: I tried to envision how this would look in the issue.   

The article  was about three eras of numismatic research - pre-internet, internet, and the Newman Portal era.  I pictured section headers, each with an appropriate image illustrating the era.  So what would the images be?  One was easy - the Newman Portal logo.  For the pre-internet days, I picked a random image of a bookshelf.  For the pre-NNP internet, it turned out I already had a funny image of an old man at an old-fashioned personal computer.  I added a fourth section where I discussed future eras, and found a rainbow picture I thought was appropriate.  As my old friend Ken Lowe would say, badda-bing, badda-boom - done. 

I could have written it myself from scratch, but with Joel's help we had a much better article, much faster.  His part didn't take too long to complete, and neither did mine.  Many hands make light work.

My other advice for my fellow editors was to take advantage of their unique perspectives and vantage points.  By dint of geography, or simple personal relationships, there are always opportunities for interesting articles, if only one thinks to ask.  Hook up with curators at a local museum or historical society and highlight numismatic connections.  You can do all of this easier and faster than people outside your location or numismatic specialty.

Finally, I told them not to be afraid to borrow material from elsewhere.  This is getting easier and easier to do with online archives like the Newman Portal.  Search around and find an earlier article that would be of interest to your readers today.  Get permission if necessary, but cut, paste and bingo - a new article.  Don't beat youself up for being lazy - you add value by curation and perspective.  Your editor's eye chooses that one item of hundreds on behalf of your readers, and your comments add value for newer collectors who may not be familiar with the material.  Your readers will appreciate your work, and you may find that it generates new discussion on the topic.  This happens every week in The E-Sylum.

I won't recap here everything that was said, but it was a very useful and productive event.  David Lisot captured it all on video, so it will be avalable in the future.

Here are some photos taken by Bruce Perdue. Thanks!

David Harper, Steve Roach, Wayne Homren

Beth Deisher, David Harper, Steve Roach, Wayne Homren on dias
David Lisot Manning video equipment, Gerry Tebben at podium

 Bourse Floor 
Bruce Perdue and I next walked downstairs to the bourse floor where I met Bourse Chairman and baseball fan Kevin Foley, who gushed over The E-Sylum, comparing it to the 1950 New York Yankees.  

I also spoke for a bit with Julian Leidman, Elongated Cent man Ray Dillard and waved to Paul Cunningham.  I took this shot of some great plaques at Paul's table.

Next I visited Dave Lange at the NGC booth.  As promised he had a few copies of his new book on hand.

Next I spoke to Darrell Luedtke, editor of the wooden money journal Bunyan's Chips.

Darrell Luedtke wearing a wooden nickel collector's hat

Darrell at the Wooden Money Table, sans hat

While wandering the bourse floor I took some time to review the exhibit area, which was quite extensive, rivaling the annual American Numismatic Association convention.  Here are  some pictures of exhibits that caught my eye.

Paper Money Errors

Maundy Coinage

Paper Money. Note the Small Heath's Counterfeit Detector

Georgia's Risque Vignettes

 The Newman Numismatic Portal 
By now E-Sylum readers are familiar with the Newman Numismatic Portal.  Len Augsburger and I gave a talk to a couple dozen attendees.  I started off with comments about Why the Portal is necessary, and len took over to discuss the What and the How.   We had some great questions from the audience.   

Afterwards I enjoyed meeting some of the attendees, including Kathy Freeland of TAMS and E-Sylum contributor Harry Waterson, whom I'd never before met in person.  Coin shows are great for nothing if not putting faces to names.

 Back On the Bourse Floor 
After the NNP meeting I went back down to the bourse floor for a while.  I visited with Ed Krivoniak and Pat McBride at the Burns library booth.  Pat has done a marvelous job creating a welcoming and colorful layout for the Burns and PAN booths.

Ed Krivoniak and Pat McBride

Pennsylvania Association of Numismatists Booth

The lots in the upcoming PAN online auction (closing May 6th) were at the table for viewing.  Pat showed me an interesting book lot: A Guide to the Coins of Great Britain & Ireland with embossed & colored plates.

To read the complete lot description, see: 

A Guide to the Coins of Great Britain & Ireland


Brad Karoleff snuck up behind me and grabbed my backpack, moving around so I couldn't see him, try as I might.  I had no idea who it was.

My time was running short, so I said my goodbyes and headed to the lobby to pick up my bag and head out to my waiting cab.  That breakfast had lasted me all day and I never did eat lunch.  Luckily I had time to grab dinner at the airport before my flight.    It was whirlwind trip, but very productive and enjoyable.  Great show!  


The biggest numismatic news hitting the workd this week was the discovery in Spain of a huge Roman coin hoard.  In sorting thru my email I believe Georges Depeyrot of Paris was the first to forward me an article.  Below are some selected images and text.

To read the complete article, see: 

El tesoro de las monedas romanas de Tomares


Robert Hoge forwarded an article and video (in Spanish).

To read the complete article, see: 

600 kilos de monedas romanas descubiertas en Tomares (Sevilla)


Alan Luedeking forwarded this first English-language story I saw on the hoard - here's an excerpt from the BBC News report.

Construction workers laying pipes in a park in southern Spain have unearthed a 600kg trove of Roman coins.
The bronze coins dating from the late 4th Century were found inside 19 Roman amphoras, a type of jar.
They bear images of the emperors Constantine and Maximian and it is thought they may have been used to pay soldiers or civil servants.

The Director of the Seville Archaeological Museum Ana Navarro said the discovery had incalculable value.
"It is a unique collection and there are very few similar cases," she said.

"I could not give you an economic value, because the value they really have is historical and you can't calculate that."

Work on the pipes, in the town of Tomares, has been suspended while an archaeological survey is carried out.
The Romans began to conquer Spain in 218 BC, ruling until the 5th Century.

To read the complete article, see: 

Spanish pipe-layers find large Roman coin hoard


Thanks also to Katie de Silva, Don Cleveland, Dick Hanscom, John Lupia, Philip Mernick, and David Sundman.


E-Sylum subscriber Noah Reynolds published an interesting article in the Winston-Salem Journal this week.  Here is Michael Breedlove's introduction to the piece.

Legend has it that when R. J. Reynolds rode into Winston-Salem in 1875 to found the R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, he had $500 and a sack of tobacco seeds in his saddlebag. What most people don’t know is that he also carried a lucky family coin with him—the Joshua Coin— that had originally belonged to his Irish great-grandfather Joshua Cox. Square in shape and silver in color, the totem was thought to be an ancient Peruvian coin that brought protection and good luck to its owner.

Stories about the coin started spreading locally in the early 1900s as Reynolds began amassing incredible wealth. Not only was the totem credited for providing his family with great fortune, it was also said to protect all those who wore it or shared its luck from harm’s way. For a time, the coin was passed down through generations of Reynolds. But at some point, it mysteriously disappeared, causing it to spiral into one of Winston-­Salem’s most mystifying tales.

Some say the coin was nothing special, simply a piece of silver with no magical powers. Others say it was more of a curse than a blessing, causing both triumphs and tragedies. Some even speculate the coin wasn’t Peruvian at all, but was actually one of the original 30 pieces of silver given to Judas for betraying Jesus.

All of this leads toward a tale with lots of questions and not a lot of answers. So, in an effort to explore the coin in more detail, we turned to Noah Reynolds for help. Not only is Noah the great-grandson of R.J. Reynolds, but he is also a coin collector and family historian who’s done extensive research on the coin and its history to separate fact from fiction. According to him, to understand the full story of the Joshua Coin, you’ve got to go back in time nearly 300 years—back to a man named Joshua Cox. We’ll let Noah take it from here…

To read the complete article, see: 

The Joshua Coin Chronicles



E-Sylum regular Howard Daniel was a participant at the recent MPC fest for collectors of Military Payment Certificates.  In a letter to the Editor published in the April 25, 2016 MPC Gram newsletter, Howard recounted how he accumulated large numbers of the notes while  serving in Vietnam.  I added an MPC image for illustration.

I was going through my "black hole" library today and found a reference which lists the name of the dealer I sent all of my MPCs to during the Vietnam War from January 1966 to January 1973.  It is Jim Wilson's House of Hobbies, Minong, WI 54859!  I had forgotten about him.

Whenever there was a change to a new MPC series, I would visit my favorite bar in Saigon and look through the owner's stash of "worthless" old series notes.  I would pick out the AU and better notes and pay her 10 Cents on the dollar.  I would first set aside the replacements and notes I needed for my collection, then create several envelopes for what I sent to Mr. Wilson.  I sent him hundreds of notes and he bought them at 10% over face!  So many of the high grade MPCs that you have seen are from Jim Wilson selling them.  His checks went to my bank account at the National Bank of Fort Lauderdale and not back to me in Vietnam.

I was also often the Pay NCO with a Pay Officer and I got a bunch of notes in my wallet ready to exchange for replacements when I saw them.  I saw VERY few of them but I got all of them still in my collection.

Fred Schwan thinks I was breaking a regulation by mailing the "old" MPC back to the USA and selling it.  Before I sent back my first envelope to Mr. Wilson, I visited the MACV Hqs JAG office and talked to a JAG officer about it.  He told me that on "C Day", the old series became scrap paper and I could do anything I wanted to do with it.

I also bought many MPCs while I was back in Vietnam from 1989.  In those early years back there, MPCs were all less than a US$ a piece.  There were sometimes suitcases of them sitting in a shop and they included the VOID and/or Evidence MPCs, which I bought!  But by the mid-1990s, the suitcases no longer appeared in the shops.

Hope you like this background information to many MPCs being in the USA and elsewhere because of what I did after "C Days" during my six years there and for five or six years from 1989.

The Master Sergeant Daniel

To read the complete issue, see: 

MPC GRAM   SERIES 11   No.2307      25 APRIL 2016
Fest XVII Report
Part 2




This event occurred last week but I didn't manage to get this into the last issue.  Thanks to David Sundman for forwarding this BBC News article.  The article acknowledges the debate over the presence of women on banknotes, which is playing out in countries around the world.

Artist JMW Turner and his painting The Fighting Temeraire will feature on the new design of the Bank of England's £20 note to enter circulation in 2020.

The English Romantic artist was chosen from a list of public nominations - the first time the Bank has asked who should appear on a specific banknote.

The note, to be made of polymer, will eventually replace the current £20 note featuring the economist Adam Smith.
The choice means all but one Bank of England banknote character will be men.

Of the five characters on banknotes by 2020, other than the Queen only Jane Austen - appearing on the £10 note from 2017 - is a woman.

The men who will feature by 2020 are Sir Winston Churchill on the £5 note who will replace campaigner Elizabeth Fry from September, Turner on the £20 note, and Matthew Boulton and James Watt remain on the £50 note.

The Bank received 29,701 nominations from the public after it announced it wanted to celebrate an artist on the note. Some 590 eligible visual artists were considered for the honour - about a fifth of whom are women.

The committee drew up a shortlist of five - Turner, filmmaker Charlie Chaplin, sculptor Barbara Hepworth, painter William Hogarth, and designer Josiah Wedgwood.
The final decision was made by the Bank's governor, Mark Carney.

He said diversity was a consideration in the decision, and he admitted that "further progress" was needed on all measures of diversity when thinking about representation on banknotes. However, he said the process was more transparent and independent now.

Joseph Mallord William Turner, or JMW Turner (1775 - 1851), is known as "the painter of light" and described by artist Tracey Emin as a "wild maverick".

To read the complete article, see: 

New £20 note design and personality unveiled by Bank of England




High quality coin supplies & other numismatic accessories. Use coupon
"coinbooks10" for an instant 10% OFF discount!


This press release details results from the recent paper money sales by Archives International Auctions. Great notes, impressive prices.


The auction was held April 11 th , 12 th and 13 th at Archives International Auctions’ offices in Fort
Lee, N.J., featuring Part 3 of the Alexander I. Pogrebetsky family archives of rare Chinese and
Asian banknotes, and the first offering from the Silicon Valley collection of worldwide banknotes

907 Peking issue 5 Taels banknote

 A high-grade Deutsch-Asiatische Bank, 1907 Peking issue 5 Taels banknote
rarity soared to a record $30,000, after opening on the floor for $14,500, at a three-day auction
held April 11-13 by Archives International Auctions, in the firm’s offices at 1580 Lemoine
Avenue (Suite 7) in Fort Lee. Additional Chinese and Russian banknote rarities also posted new
world record prices.

“The success of this auction, with specific regard to the many Chinese, Asian and Russian
banknotes that set new price records, clearly proved that the banknote and coin market in these
areas is as active and vibrant as ever, with multiple buyers across the globe and aggressive
competition for rare and unique items,” said Dr. Robert Schwartz, President of Archives
International Auctions.

Over 1,700 lots of United States, Chinese, Russian and worldwide banknotes, coins, scripophily
(stocks and bonds) and security printing ephemera were offered over the course of the three days.
Featured were additional banknotes from the Alexander I. Pogrebetsky family archives of rare
Chinese and Asian banknotes, and the initial offering from the Silicon Valley collection of
worldwide banknotes.

Session 1, on April 11 th , featured U.S. and worldwide banknotes and scripophily. Session 2, on
April 12 th , contained Russian and worldwide banknotes and Chinese scripophily. Session 3, on
April 13 th , featured Chinese banknotes and scrip notes. Nearly all the Chinese and Russian notes
were from longstanding collections assembled over many decades and never previously offered.

Session I, began with world banknotes, featuring the Silicon Valley collection and numerous
consignors banknotes. French Colonial notes were big hits and included a French Guiana, 1961,
500 Francs graded Gem Unc. 65 that sold for $1,140; and 1 Rupee, 1957 and 5 Rupees, 1959,
Government of India “Persian Gulf Note” issues that brought for $885 and $3,540, respectively;

Also sold was a Jordan Currency Board, 1952 Issue, 500 Fils with special serial # B/A 700007
that gaveled for $1,770; a rare Oman Currency Board specimen set of eight denominations in
Choice AU to Gem Uncirculated condition, rarely seen in this format, that realized $6,000; and
an unassuming lot of Chile banknote rarities that had been cut in half achieved an amazing

Session II began with worldwide banknotes from Pacific Rim and Asian countries. Highlights
included 25 Rupiah and 50 Rupiah essay specimens by Security Bank Note Company that rose to
$1,140 and $1,020, respectively; a Japan, 1 Yen Coiled Dragon Silver Dollar, M34 (1901) in MS
65 ($708); and a Royal Thai Mint Double Coin presentation set, circa 1944 to 1963 (also $708).

1920 All Russian Central Union of Consumer Societies Specimen

In addition, 101 lots of Chinese railroad and related bonds were sold out of the 102 lots offered,
with most lots bringing $250-$500. Russian notes included two Vladikavkaz Railroad Co., 1918,
5,000 and 10,000 Rubles notes that sold for $885 and $944, respectively; a 1920, 500 Rubles,
Russian Central Union of Consumers Societies Specimen ($4,427); and a circa 1918-20 Torgsin
Soviet Trading Fleet 3 Rubles Scrip Note that ended up selling for a very impressive $11,400.

Session III highlights of Chinese banknotes and scrip notes included eight different Imperial
Ch’ing Dynasty banknotes, including a 100,000 Cash, 1858 ($11,400); and a pair of 3 Taels and
5 Taels Board of Revenue banknotes that finished at $4,800 and $5,605, respectively. Also, a
group of Alexander I. Pogrebetsky banknotes used as the photographic examples on the
matching pages from his 1929 numismatic book hammered for between $620 and $4,720.

A Central Bank of China, 1949 5,000 Gold Chin Yuan essay specimen by Security Bank Note
Company breezed to $3,658; while a 1923 National Commercial Bank, Ltd., issue pair gaveled
for $1,475. People’s Republic issues were highlighted by a 1949, 5 Yuan, P-14a high grade
example that went for an impressive $6,000 after intense bidding between the floor and internet.

1909  Netherlands Trading Society banknote

Chinese foreign banks featured a Netherlands Trading Society, $10, 1909 issue note ($4,800);
and a Peiyang Tientsin Bank, 3 Taels, 1910 issue ($8,075). Chinese scrip notes featured a large
collection of Harbin notes, highlighted by a circa 1920-30’s banknote pair from Harbin Bakery
($3,186); a Society of Artisans Club, 1919 Harbin issue ($6,300); and a Hulunbeier Business
Bank, 1919 scrip note ($3,120).

Archives International Auctions is always looking for U.S. and worldwide banknotes, coins,
stocks, bonds, stamps, postal history, autographs and historic ephemera and documents for future
auctions, or to buy outright. To sell or consign one piece or an entire collection, you may call
AIA at (201) 944-4800; or you can send them an e-mail to 

info at

You may also write to Archives International Auctions, at 1580 Lemoine Ave., Suite #7, Fort
Lee, NJ 07024 U.S.A. To learn more about Archives International Auctions and their upcoming
summer and fall auctions, log on to Updates are posted often.


Coin collecting is a universal hobby, with enthrusiasts worldwide.  Here's a story from Malaysia about collectors snapping up new commemorative coins.


AFTER waiting for five hours amid the heatwave, an avid collector walked away all smiles with a set of commemorative coins in his possession.

The coins were recently launched by Bank Negara Malaysia to mark the 70th anniversary of Radio Televisyen Malaysia (RTM).

Koay Cheng San, 66, who had been collecting coins for the past 30 years, turned up at the bank’s Penang branch in Light Street, George Town, at about 5am.

He said there were already eight people waiting in queue even though the bank only opened at 8.45am.

“I managed to get my hands on 10 Nordic gold brilliant uncirculated coins with a face value of RM1 for RM10.60 each.

“I also got a RM10 silver commemorative coin for RM212. I am sure this coin can fetch up to RM600 in the near future,” said the elated pensioner.

Koay revealed that he had wanted to buy another set later, but the coins were already sold out by then.

Another passionate coin collector, Ong Joe Sin, 13, came all the way from Bukit Mertajam and waited for almost four hours.

“I’ve been collecting coins since nine as I find them very interesting and valuable. I bought these commemorative coins using my own savings,” he said.

The silver and Nordic gold brilliant uncirculated commemorative coins are limited to only 500 and 10,000 pieces respectively.

The coins, also available in a set of two, are limited to 2,000 sets. It has the iconic image of RTM’s headquarters, Angkasapuri, which has a unique facade decorated with a motif based on the shape of the tongue.

To read the complete article, see: 

Collectors brave hot spell to queue up for special coins



Kerry Wetterstrom forwarded this press release for the upcoming sale 3102 from Classical Numismatic Group. Thanks.  Some amazing coins and medals here.

Classical Numismatic Group is proud to present
CNG 102, an Internet and Mail Bid Sale closing electronically on
Wednesday, 18 May 2016, from 10 AM ET (U.S.). This sale offers 1571
lots with a presale estimate in excess of $2,900,000.

Our annual spring sale features Greek, Celtic, Oriental Greek, Central
Asian, Roman Provincial, Republican, and Imperial coinage.
Additionally, there are featured selections of Byzantine, Early Medieval,
Islamic, World, World Medals, British, and British Medals.

General selections of coins are included throughout the sale from the
estate of Thomas Bentley Cederlind and the collection of J. Eric Engstrom.

The Greek section is also highlighted by coins from the named
collections of Allan Smith M.D., Byron Schieber, M.A. Armstrong, Colin
E. Pitchfork, and Dr. Will Gordon. In addition, there are selections of
fractions from the AG collection and electrum from the LVL collection.
Many of these coins enjoy earlier pedigrees. The Oriental Greek section
includes an offering of 20 Parthian tetradrachms and several important
pieces of Baktrian gold.

In the Republican and Imperial section, one will find offerings from the
Volteia, Schieber, and LVL collections in addition to coins from
Cederlind and Engstrom. The Imperial section offers over 90 Roman
aurei and a nice selection of Roman bronzes, many from the Cederlind
estate. Tom took great pride in the bronzes he had in inventory, as all are
free from many of the problems one normally encounters with bronzes on the market today.

The Byzantine section offers coins from the M.A. Armstrong collection,
which includes a number of Sear Byzantine Coins and Their Values plate
coins. The early Medieval section is highlighted by coins from the R.D.
Frederick Collection and the Cederlind estate, while the World section
includes further selections from Engstrom, Cederlind, and Group SGF.
Of special note is a nice selection of Viking related coinage that can be
found under Denmark and Sweden.

CNG 102 features a strong selection of English coinage. This section is
comprised of 160 lots, and includes coins from the Cederlind estate, the
R.D. Frederick, Dr. Andrew Wayne, and LVL collections. Included from
Dr. Wayne are a number of rare Saxon mints, and the LVL offering
consists of 19 pieces of Scottish gold.

The World and British sections conclude with offering of medals that
include several rare Dutch pieces in gold and the Eimer plate coin for the
Charles I, Dominion of the Sea medal.

This well-rounded sale offers something for everyone. Catalogs have
been mailed to our active mailing list and bidding is open on the site.

Some of the individual highlights from CNG 102 are:

In the style of Eukleidas

LOT 155–SICILY, Syracuse. Dionysios I. 405-367 BC. AR Tetradrachm (25.5mm,
17.22 g, 3h). In the style of Eukleidas. Struck circa 405-400 BC. Charioteer, holding
kentron in right hand and reins in both, driving fast quadriga left; above, Nike flying
right, crowning charioteer with wreath held in both hands; in exergue, dolphin right /
Head of Arethousa left, hair in band, wearing double-loop earring and plain necklace
with frontal pendant; [Σ-Y-PAK- O-ΣI-ΩN above hair], four dolphins around. Tudeer
104 (dies 35/71); HGC 2, 1345; SNG ANS 300; BMC 197; Boston MFA 444;
Jameson 809; de Luynes 1208; Rizzo pl. XXXXVIII, 16 (all from the same dies).
Near EF, attractive cabinet tone, reverse a touch off center. Estimated at $5,000.

>From the Allan Smith, M.D. Collection. Ex Gorny & Mosch 190 (11 October 2010),
lot 67; Gorny & Mosch 112 (17 October 2001), lot 4036; Peter M. Suter Collection
(Münzen und Medaillen AG 89, 14 June 2000), lot 83; Münzen und Medaillen AG 66
(22 October 1984), lot 43.

Exceptional Winged Monster
Arguments for Daimon and for Mithraic Areimanios

LOT 366–MYSIA, Kyzikos. Circa 550-500 BC. EL Stater (18mm, 15.87 g). Winged
male mythological creature running-kneeling left, head right, holding tunny by its tail
in left hand / Quadripartite incuse square. Von Fritze I 123; Greenwell 57; SNG
France 271; Boston MFA 1457 = Warren 1471; SNG von Aulock 1198 = Kraay &
Hirmer 704 = L. Mildenberg, “Über das Münzwesen im Reich der Achämeniden” in
AMI 26 (1993), pl. VII, 62; Gulbenkian 617; Jameson 2560; Weber –. Near EF,
lightly toned. Well-centered, struck from artistic dies. Very rare and exceptional for
issue. Estimated at $50,000.

>From the LVL Collection.

While the identification of this creature, certainly of local significance, is unknown
today, it has traditionally been referred to as “Phobos” or “Daimon.” In his catalog of
the Gulbenkian collection, Jenkins sees an Egyptian or near-Eastern influence, while
Bivar, in his article on Mithra (“Mithra and Mesopotamia,” Mithraic Studies
[Manchester, 1975], pp. 275-89), suggests that the creature corresponds to the
Mithraic Areimanios (Ahriman). One also may see an assimilation of the ubiquitous
Persian lion-headed griffin, adapting the head, wings, and tail to a human body.
Although some references note the head as being that of a wolf, other examples
clearly show a mane that is directly influenced by the lion heads on the common early
Lydian electrum, supporting Bivar’s (and others’) contention that it is a lion head. At
the same time, the ear is not fully visible on most examples, but on some, such as the
present piece, it clearly is that of a griffin (compare to its depiction on the coins of
Teos and Abdera). The wings and posture of the creature are mythological archetypes,
commonly found on displays of various deities and creatures on pottery and coins. An
excellent example of an archaic representation of a local deity of Asia Minor.

The Delphic Omphalos

LOT 378–MYSIA, Kyzikos. 5th-4th centuries BC. EL Stater (16.5mm, 16.03 g).
Two eagles standing facing each other on ornamented omphalos; below, tunny right /
Quadripartite incuse square. Von Fritze I 220; Greenwell 22; SNG France 348;
Boston MFA 1535 = Warren 1440. Near EF. Rare. Estimated at $20,000.

>From the LVL Collection.

This rare type depicts the legend of the omphalos (navel) stone, which marked the
sacred precinct of the sanctuary of Apollo at Delphi as the physical center of the
earth. According to tradition, two eagles, which had been released by Zeus, one flying
from the east, and the other from the west, met exactly at the site of Apollo’s
sanctuary. This spot was marked for all to see by the stone omphalos, and designated
as the center of the earth. The omphalos was a white stone ornamented with stripes of
various kinds, and upon it were the representations of the two eagles (as seen on this
coin type – the tunny fish below is the city-badge of Kyzikos). This scene was
frequently represented in vase-paintings, but is extremely rare on coinage. The
omphalos probably stood on the sacred hearth that was in the center of the temple.

The origins of Apollo’s temple at Delphi are described in the Homeric Hymn to
Apollo. Apollo descended from Mt. Olympos and made his way through northern and
central Greece until he finally found the proper site for the foundation of his oracle at
Crisa under the snow-capped Mt. Parnassos. He laid out his temple and then slew a
she-dragon, which inhabited the area. The name of the site was subsequently called
Pytho (and Apollo, the Pythian) due to the rotting body of the slain dragon. (The verb
pytho, in Greek, means ‘to rot’.) Interestingly enough, Zeus punished Apollo for the
murder of the dragon by exiling him to Thessaly for nine years. A religious festival
called the Stepteria was celebrated every ninth year at Delphi to commemorate these
events associated with the foundation myth of the sanctuary.

After Apollo established his sanctuary, he went about the business of recruiting
attendants for the temple. He noticed a ship passing by, manned by Cretans from
Knossos, and on their way to Pylos. Apollo transformed himself into a dolphin
(δελφις, hence the name of the city) and leaped aboard the Cretan ship. At first the
men tried to throw the dolphin back into the sea, but they were “awed” by it into a
“fearful submission”. After a lengthy voyage, Apollo led the ship to Crisa, where “he
leaped ashore and revealed himself as a god amid a blaze of fiery brightness and
splendor”. He ordered the Cretan men to perform sacrifices and to pray to him as
Apollo Delphinius. He then led them to his sanctuary and placed the Cretans in
charge, predicting great wealth and prestige for his temple.

This story linked the early cult of Apollo to Crete and promoted Apollo as the god of
sailors and colonization. His oracle at Delphi played a major role as the religious
impetus for the Greeks in establishing their colonies, hence its importance to the
residents of Kyzikos, itself a colony of Miletos. The importance of this coin type to
Kyzikos may also be found in another story that has the city being settled by the
Pelasgi from Thessaly, who were driven from Thessaly by the Aeolians. Their king
and leader was Kyzikos, a son of Apollo, who gave his name to the city and thus
established its link to Apollo and his temple at Delphi.

Exceptional Tyrian Quarter Shekel

LOT 628–PHOENICIA, Tyre. Uncertain king. Circa 425-394 BC. AR Quarter
Shekel (15.5mm, 2.90 g, 9h). Melkart, holding bow in extended left hand and reins in
right, riding hippocamp right; below, waves above dolphin right / Owl standing right,
head facing; crook and flail diagonally in background. E&E-T Group II.1.1.2;
Rouvier 1789; HGC 10, 324. Near EF, toned, slight roughness, scuff on reverse.
Exceptional for issue, rare in this condition. Estimated at $2,000.

One of Thirteen Known

LOT 706–BAKTRIA, Indo-Greek Kingdom. Menander I Soter. Circa 155-130
BC. AV Stater (20mm, 8.57 g, 1h). Draped bust of Athena right, wearing crested
helmet adorned with wing; all within bead-and- reel border / Owl standing right on
ground line, head facing; A to left; all within bead-and- reel border. Bopearachchi 1A;
MIG Type 211a (same obv. die as top example); SNG ANS 682; Boston MFA Supp.
312; Treasures of Ancient Bactria (Miho Museum), 46a (same dies); HGC 12, 494.
EF, lightly toned, area of weak strike on obverse at periphery. Extremely rare, one of
13 specimens known. Estimated at $50,000.

Unlike his silver and bronze issues, the gold coinage of Menander I Soter is very rare
(as is the case with Baktrian gold issues in general). This stater, with the helmeted
head of Athena on the obverse and an owl on the reverse, is among the rarest, with a
total of 13 specimens known. Mitchiner questioned the authenticity of some of the
specimens he recorded, but did not doubt the British Museum specimen, which is
struck from the same obverse die as the present coin. Bopearachchi, in a note on the
series, repeated Mitchiner’s reservation without further elucidation. S. Hurter, in her
review of Le portrait d’Alexandre le Grand by O. Bopearachchi and P. Flandrin in
SNR 85 (2006), expressed doubt about a number of the coins in the Miho Museum
and suggested that the Miho Menander (which she had not seen) should undergo
further examination (pp. 190–1).

Unique & Unpublished Nerva Aureus

LOT 924–Nerva. AD 96-98. AV Aureus (19mm, 7.59 g, 5h). Rome mint. Struck AD
98. IMP NERVA CAES AVG GERM P M TR P II, laureate head right / IMP II COS
IIII P P, Aequitas standing facing, head left, holding scales in right hand and cradling
cornucopia in left arm. Cf. RIC II 44 for type (denarius), otherwise unpublished. EF,
lustrous. Unique. Estimated at $50,000.

A heretofore unknown and unpublished aureus for Nerva with the reverse legend of
IMP II COS IIII P P. This Aequitas type is known for a denarius (RIC II 44), but only
as an aureus with the AEQVITAS AVGVST reverse inscription. For this particular
issue, there are six denarii types with only three corresponding aurei types (Fortuna,
priestly implements, and clasped hands with legionary aquila on prow), so it stands to
reason that the three previously unlisted aurei types (Aequitas–this coin, Libertas, and
clasped hands) may eventually come to light.

Extremely Rare Didia Clara Aureus

LOT 1024–Didia Clara. Augusta, AD 193. AV Aureus (20mm, 6.80 g, 12h). Rome
mint. Struck under Didius Julianus. DIDIA CLA RA AVG, draped bust right / HILA
R TEMPOR, Hilaritas standing left, holding in left hand a long palm frond set on
ground and cradling cornucopia in right arm. RIC IV 10 (Julianus); Calicó 2402
(same obv. die as illustration); BMCRE 13 (Julianus) var. (obv. legend break); Biaggi
1053 (same obv. die); NAC 38, lot 94 (same dies); NAC 54, lot 483 (same dies). Near
EF, a couple of very light scratches. Extremely rare. Estimated at $50,000.

Hercules and the Centaur – Unpublished Variety

LOT 1089–Maximianus. First reign, AD 286-305. AV Aureus (19mm, 5.31 g, 6h).
Rome mint. Struck AD 295-305. MAXIMIA NVS P F AVG, laureate head right /
VIR TVS AV GG, Hercules standing right, leaning on hindquarters of centaur with
his left knee and grasping the head of centaur with his left hand, holding upright club
with his right hand, lion skin flowing behind his waist; the centaur is rearing up to the
right, his head left, left hand raised in defense. RIC VI –; Depeyrot 5B/8 var. (bust
draped and cuirassed); cf. Calicó 4740(obv.)/4739(rev.). Superb EF, perfectly
centered. Very rare reverse type and an unpublished variety. Estimated at $50,000.

Wonderful Depiction of Isis Riding Sothis

LOT 1105–Valentinian I. AD 364-375. Æ Medallion (24mm, 6.98 g, 12h). Festival
of Isis commemorative. Rome mint. D N VALENTIN ANVS P F AVG, pearl-
diademed and cuirassed bust right / VOT A PV B LIC A, Isis seated facing, her head
right, holding sistrum with her right hand and a scepter with her left, on Sothis
running right, who is looking back at her. Alföldi, Festival 90 (pl. XII, 16). Good VF,
brown and tan surfaces with touches of green, holed in antiquity. Estimated at $3,000.

>From the estate of Thomas Bentley Cederlind.

The Ptolemaic cult of Serapis and Isis enjoyed great popularity throughout Hellenistic
and Roman times, and indeed the Romans, like the Greeks and Persians before them,
were fascinated by the culture and monuments of ancient Egypt. The Ptolemies and
the Roman emperors were not content with just being the foreign rulers of Egypt, but
wanted to be viewed as legitimate successors of the Pharaohs. To this end, the
Romans portrayed themselves as Pharaohs to the native population and even
promoted the import of certain aspects of Egyptian culture and religion to their own
native lands. The Egyptian concept of the Pharaoh as a god was appealing to the
Roman emperors (the aging Julius Caesar was especially taken with this concept
during his romance with Cleopatra).

The Isis festival was a major celebration in Rome in the 3rd and 4th centuries,
heralding the arrival of the ship of Isis (navigium Isidis) from Alexandria on 5 March.
Besides Isis and Horus, other members of the Egyptian pantheon appear–Serapis,
Anubis, Harpocrates, and Nilus. Such coins or tokens with imperial busts were first
struck by Diocletian at Rome to mark the arrival of the ship, and the tradition
continued through the 4th century; the latest imperial bust to appear is that of
Valentinian II. Alföldi proposes that in the Middle Ages the festival associated with
the Isis ship (also known as carrus navalis) became the car naval or carnival.

Extremely Rare Fatehpur Mint Zodiac Mohur
Constellation of Varak/Mesha (Aries the Ram)

LOT 1310–INDIA, Mughal Empire. Nur al-Din Muhammad Jahangir. AH 1014-
1037 / AD 1605-1627. AV Mohur (22mm, 11.86 g, 10h). Zodiac Type, Class A.
Fatehpur mint. Dually dated AH 1028 and RY 14 (19 December AD 1618 – 14/23
October AD 1619). Constellation of Varak/Mesha (Aries the Ram): ram, head right,
recumbent left; radiate sun behind; sanat 14 jalus (regnal year 14) in Persian below /
sikka-e zar gist ba-Fatahpur faruzada nur-i nam Jahangir Shah Akbar Shah (Gold
coin became lustrous at Fatehpur by the light of the name of Jahangir Shah [son of]
Akbar Shah) in Persian verse; AH date in lower left. Cf. Liddle Type G-74/G- 76 (for
obv./rev.) = S. Bhandare, “Important Indian coins in the Kunsthistorisches; Museum,
Vienna,” in ONS Journal 205 (Autumn 2010), Fig. 7/11 (for obv./rev. – same dies as
illustrations); BM –; Wright –; Hull –; Nagpur –; Lucknow –; KM 180.2 (date
unlisted) and cf. 150. 3 (rupee); cf. Friedberg 762 (for type with no distinction to
mint). Good VF, field marks, two shroff marks on obverse, three on reverse, with
ornate suspension loop attached. Extremely rare. Estimated at $20,000.

Legitimacy of the Jacobite Succession

LOT 1571–temp. HANOVER. Charles Edward Stuart ‘Bonnie Prince Charlie’.
1720-1788. AV Medal (52mm, 74.55 g, 12h). Legitimacy of the Jacobite Succession.
By T. Pingo. A later strike from dies made c. 1750. PRINCE CHARLES EDWARD
STUART, bare head right / Charles in highland dress standing left, extending hand to
Scotia standing right, holding spear and resting hand on shield; cornucopia on ground
between; to left, Unicorn seated right on plinth; castle and ships in background;
SEMPER ARMIS NUNC/ ET INDUSTRIA (Always with arms and now with
diligence). Woolf 64.1 (unlisted in gold); Eimer, Pingo 6; MI 656/360 (unlisted in
gold); Eimer 626. Choice EF, light die rust on reverse as usual. Considerable luster.
Extremely rare in Gold. Includes old collection ticket. Estimated at $10,000.

Ex Property of a Gentleman (Sotheby’s New York, 8 December 1992), lot 193,
purchased from I. Snyderman (Art Trading Company), 16 January 1959; J. Pierpont
Morgan Collection; reportedly also ex Thomas Fortune Ryan Collection.

Printed catalogs for CNG 102 are now available. To order the catalog, please call our
U.S. office at (717) 390-9194. Catalogs have been mailed to customers on CNG’s
active mailing list. Prospective bidders may also view the virtual catalogs at CNG 102
Virtual Catalog. The sale can be viewed online
at, and 

In addition to Internet & Mail Bid Sale 102, CNG will also feature over 850 lots from
many of the same collections listed above in their Electronic Auction 375, closing two
weeks later on Wednesday, June 1, 2016, from 10AM ET (U.S.). Bidding for CNG
Electronic Auction 375 will begin on May 11, 2016.

CNG is currently accepting consignments for future auctions sales. Please contact the
firm for further details and consignment deadlines.

For further details and any additional information, please contact CNG, Inc. at:

Classical Numismatic Group, Inc.
Lancaster, PA 17608-0479
Telephone: (717) 390-9194
Email: cng at


This April 21, 2016 Atlas Obscura article caught my eye because of the great library photographs, but it may interest numismatic researchers and publishers, for very different reasons.

All around the world, shadow libraries keep growing, filled with banned materials. But no actual papers trade hands: everything is digital, and the internet-accessible content is not banned for shocking content so much as that modern crime, copyright infringement.

But for the people who run the world’s pirate libraries, their goals are no less ambitious for their work’s illicit nature.

“It’s the creation of a universal library of the best stuff,” says Joe Karaganis, who studies media piracy at Columbia University’s policy think tank, American Assembly. “That will not include the latest Danielle Steel novel.”

It does, however, include hundreds of thousands of books and millions of journal articles that otherwise are found only through expensive academic journals. Scanned or downloaded from journal sites, they are available through pirate libraries for free.

The creators of these repositories are a small group who try to keep a low profile, since distributing copyrighted material in this way is illegal. Many of them are academics. The largest pirate libraries have come from Russia’s cultural orbit, but the documents they collect are used by people around the world, in countries both wealthy and poor. Pirate libraries have become so popular that in 2015, Elsevier, one of the largest academic publishers in America, went to court to try to shut down two of the most popular, Sci-Hub and Library Genesis.

These libraries, Elsevier alleged, cost the company millions of dollars in lost profits. But the people who run and support pirate libraries argue that they’re filling a market gap, providing access to information to researchers around the world who wouldn’t have the resources to obtain these materials any other way.

The lawsuits, wrote one group of pirate library supporters, “come as a big blow” to researchers whose only source of scholarly material is in these sites. “The social media, mailing lists and IRC channels have been filled with their distress messages, desperately seeking articles and publications,” the brief states.

In other words, they believe there are researchers who are never going to be able to pay the steep price of academic articles; either they use pirate libraries, which give them efficient access to information, or they don’t get to read those books and journals at all.

The photos, of course, are of legitimate world libraries.
I have no idea if numismatic content is among the holdings in these shadow repositories, but copyright holders might want to investigate.

To read the complete article, see: 

The Rise of Pirate Libraries




We've covered this unusual (and creepy) topic before, but while reading the above Atlas Obscura article, the web site recommended this one - a listing of bizarre books bound in human skin.

Leather-bound books are one of the finest ways to give your library a sense of gravitas and history. But books bound in human skin communicate more of a "serial killer" or "necromancer" vibe. Nonetheless, morbid tomes are fascinating artifacts from a time when gruesome human relics could still be created without winding someone up in jail. They are rare, but here are three places that still hold copies of books made out of a human's tanned epidermis.

Edinburgh, Scotland

Scotland's Royal College of Surgeons at Edinburgh houses a great deal of interesting and somewhat morbid artifacts, but the most intriguing relate to the famous grave-robbing and murdering duo, Burke and Hare. In the late 1820s, the pair of dastardly entrepreneurs realized that they could make a pretty penny selling corpses to the surgeon's college for use as anatomical test templates. Unfortunately coming across naturally deceased corpses is a bit tricky and so the pair started making their own. They ended up murdering 16 people for the scheme by the time they were caught. Hare was released, but Burke was hung, dissected, and a book and card case were made of his skin, as though his life had not been morbid enough. Today the small notebook can still be found sitting under Burke's death mask in the college's museum, looking like a rather classy Moleskine. 

Boston, Massachusetts

When anthropodermic bibliopegy, or the practice of binding a book in human skin, was in vogue, it was often used as a chronicle of a criminal and their deeds. Not unlike Burke above, convicted criminals would be executed, and their skin would be removed to create a book that detailed their offenses. Just such a book is still held in a box in the Boston Athenaeum. Written by the bandit John Allen, and bound in his skin at his own request, the full title of the book is, Narrative of the Life of James Allen, alias Jonas Pierce, alias James H. York, alias Burley Grove, the Highwayman, Being His Death-bed Confession to the Warden of the Massachusetts State Prison. It is certainly a grim way to be remembered, but honestly, you can't get much more personal that a memoir held in your own skin. 

Providence, Rhode Island

Other than criminals, the other main contributors to the genre of skin books were doctors. It was not uncommon for unique anatomical texts to be bound in the skin of a cadaver. The John Hay Library in Providence, Rhode Island has one such volume, as well as a pair of other skin books that are simply creepy. The book, De Humanis Corporis Fabrica (On the Fabric of the Human Body), is an early medical text written in the 1500s, but the copy in the John Hay Library was rebound in human skin in 1898. The other two skin books in the collection, which were also only rebound in the late-1800s are copies of The Dance of Death, collections of medieval woodcuts depicting the various ways people can die, via little tableaus of scythe wielding skeletons and the like.  

To read the complete article, see: 

Shelfies: 3 Places to Find Books Bound in Human Skin


To read the earlier E-Sylum articles, see: 








This week's Featured Web Site is The Royal Numismatic Society.

The Royal Numismatic Society is the UK’s foremost society for numismatics – the study of coins, medals and related currency items.

Founded in 1836 as The Numismatic Society of London, today’s Society is international in subject and membership. Its lectures and publications deal with Classical, Asian, Medieval and Modern coins, paper money, tokens and medals, and Fellows include scholars and enthusiasts from around the world.

Meetings are held on the third Tuesday of the month between October and June, usually at The Warburg Institute, 6pm to 7.30pm, and are open to all. 

The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. For more information please
see our web site at

There is a membership application available on the web site
at this address:

To join, print the application and return it with your check
to the address printed on the application. Membership is only
$15 to addresses in the U.S., $20 for First Class mail, and
$25 elsewhere.  For those without web access, write to:

David M. Sundman, Secretary/Treasurer
Numismatic Bibliomania Society,
P. O. Box 82 Littleton, NH 03561

For Asylum mailing address changes and other membership
questions, contact David at this email address:
dsundman at

To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, just
Reply to this message, or write to the Editor at this
address: whomren at <!-- at>

Those wishing to become new E-Sylum subscribers
(or wishing to Unsubscribe) can go to the following web page:

All past E-Sylum issues are archived on the NBS web site at this address:

Issues from September 2002 to date are also archived at this address:

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <>

More information about the Esylum mailing list