The E-Sylum v6#03, January 19, 2003
whomren at coinlibrary.com
whomren at coinlibrary.com
Sun Jan 19 18:53:08 PST 2003
Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 6, Number 3, January 19, 2003:
an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
Copyright (c) 2002, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
SUBSCRIBER UPDATE
Among recent new subscribers is Martin Logies,
courtesy of W. David Perkins. Welcome aboard!
We now have 514 subscribers.
UPCOMING DAVIS SALE
Charles Davis writes: "My next auction will include duplicates
from the American Numismatic Society and others. Included
are plated Chapman Lyman, Beckwith and Cleneay catalogues,
a 22-plate Elder Lawrence catalogue, plated Mortimer
Mackenzie sale, numerous volumes of the AJN, early issues
of The Numismatist, and an early Berlin periodical containing
perhaps the first published numismatic photograph. The sale
will close February 15 and catalogues are now in the mail."
SPRINGARN MEDAL
Monday is Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. day in the U.S.
Dr. King was awarded a number of medals, including the
Spingarn Medal.
"In 1915 the NAACP initiated the Springarn Medal to be
awarded annually for outstanding achievement by a black
American. The first award was won by Dr. Ernest Everett
Just, a 32-year old marine biologist from Charleston, South
Carolina. Head of the Howard University Department of
the Zoology at the time, Dr. Just was the only person to
graduate magna cum laude from Dartmouth college with a
degree in zoology, special honors in botany and history,
and honors in sociology.
Over the years the Springarn Medal has come to signify
the highest honor available from the NAACP. Although
the significance of the organization declined with the
culmination of the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s, the
Springarn Medal remains a coveted award. Past winners
include statesmen (Ralph Bunche, Martin Luther King),
musicians (Marian Anderson, Duke Ellington), authors
(Maya Angelou, Alex Haley), politicians (Barbara Jordan,
Andrew Young), civil rights leaders (Medger Evans, Rosa
Parks), athletes (Jackie Robinson, Hank Aaron), and
entertainers (Paul Robeson, Bill Cosby)."
[Excerpted from "The History of the Springarn Medal"
http://or.essortment.com/springarnmedal_rlwp.htm.
Other web references include:
http://www.lfpl.org/reference/rflksgarn.htm
http://spingarn.k12.dc.us/sclub/medal.html
In my searches of the web I've been unable to find an
image of this medal. Has anyone ever seen one? Or
know anything about the design and designer? -Editor]
WASHINGTON STATE MEDALS
Terry Trantow writes: "I am always amazed at the range of
news and comments, search requests and informational items
the E-Sylum provides. I read more than I can offer, but came
across this site regarding the medals of honor and valor given
by the State of Washington each year, which is currently open
for nominations. A picture of the obverse[s] of the medal[s] is
provided, which depicts a somewhat unattractive-looking piece.
The site is http://www.secstate.wa.gov/Medals.
NOTIFY YOUR HEIRS: COPYRIGHTS GOOD 70 YEARS.
Dick Johnson reports: "The Supreme Count upheld, on
Wednesday, January 15th, the extension of United States
Copyrights by 20 years. Authors' heirs can now collect
royalties for 70 years from the date of death of the author.
For numismatic authors this could gain some royalty money
for their estates. For numismatic publishers, you will have
to wait a while to reprint that numismatic classic for free.
Previously the length of an American copyright was life
of the artist plus 50 years. The new legislation (upheld by
the Supreme Court) introduced in 1998 and known as the
Sony Bono law, changed the law to be life of the artist plus
70 years. This brings our copyright law more in line with
that in Europe.
For works copyrighted by corporations, it dates from year
first published. Formerly it was 75 years. Now it is 95 years.
Those in favor of the changing the law were concentrated in
Hollywood, as early movies were approaching the deadline
for this copyright protected work to pass into public domain.
Had this not been approved by the Supreme Count, we
could have had "Steamboat Willie" Mickey Mouse all over
the internet."
NEW BOOK: GREENBACK
The January 9, 2003 issue of the Christian Science Monitor
published a review of a new book, "Greenback: The Almighty
Dollar and the Invention of America" by Jason Goodwin,
published Henry Holt, 321 pp., $26.
"The billions of electronic dollars zipping from computer to
computer each day provoke an interesting question: What
really is an American dollar? British author and journalist
Jason Goodwin takes a crack at the answer with "Greenback,"
a biography of the buck that traces it from native American
wampum to today's almighty bill.
It is a riveting story with a quirky cast of early American
characters that includes a few of the Founding Fathers,
inventors, counterfeiters, secret agents, bankers, and
swindlers, each placing their thumbprint on the young
country's currency and monetary system, whether they
knew it or not."
For the full review, see:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0109/p17s01-bogn.html
From Publishers Weekly (published on Amazon.com, where
the book is offered for $18.20):
"After a strong start, this history of American money loses
its thread and ends up as an entertaining collection of trivia,
personality profiles and vignettes rather than the compelling
narrative promised in its opening. Still, Goodwin's flair for a
colorful tale makes for rich reading, covering such odds and
ends as a brothel in the Treasury Department, a prayer vigil
over banking deposits, exploding printing presses and even
a counterfeit scheme run from behind prison bars. Goodwin
(Lords of the Horizons) makes some excellent points about
the role of paper money in early U.S. history-it was the
earliest symbol of the new country; it helped push colonists
West; it even helped familiarize Americans with their native
artists-but the significance of the stories he's chosen to include
isn't always clear. After presenting a single national currency
as one of the holy grails of early American banking, for
instance, he glosses over the moment it finally arrives, a true
turning point in American financial history. Goodwin's position
as a foreign observer (he is an English journalist) occasionally
trips him up: no one in America, for example, says "that will
be four dollars thirty six."
The more I learn about numismatic history, the less surprised
I am to read about various scandals. Somehow, I think I
would have remembered reading about a brothel in the
Treasury Department. Unless it's something new, perhaps
staffed by holdover interns from the Clinton Administration...
Alas, according to another Amazon reviewer, the book has
no footnotes or endnotes. Does anyone know of a source
for the Treasury brothel story? Perhaps he's referring to the
Spencer Clark scandals. From an earlier review of
the book in The New York Times, December 29, 2002:
"But once in motion, the dollar rewarded fellow raconteurs
like Spencer Morton Clark, who ran the currency bureau
during the Civil War era like a personal harem, and tried to
slip his own face onto a five-cent bill. Goodwin observes,
with typical wry amusement, ''Queer things had turned up
on dollar bills in the past, from Santa Claus to the Delaware
rat, but nothing to match the appearance, on a U.S. note, of
a bankrupt sex pest under investigation for embezzlement
and fraud.''
Benny Bolin wrote a good article on Clark, originally
published in Paper Money, the journal of the Society of
Paper Money Collectors. It has since been posted to the
web: http://www.fractionalnotes.com/spencerclarkarticle.htm
"Due to the war and the subsequent shortage of available male
workers, it became a necessity for a large number of women
to be hired to work in the printing department. This was a new
and radical idea in the workplace. The private bank note
companies used this new idea, especially the fact that a large
number of women were employed at night, to raise charges
against the bureau. Charges of fraud and promiscuity rocked
the Treasury Department. Reports of drinking, orgies and
required sexual favors to keep jobs were numerous. It was
widely reported that the printing bureau had been converted
into a place for debauchery and drinking, the very recital
of which is impossible without violating decency."
FROSSARD SALE OF CLARK COLLECTION
Also online is the October 1893 "Special List No. 8"
of Clark's "Unique Collection of Essays & Proofs of
United States Fractional Currency"
http://www.fractionalnotes.com/frossardsaleofclarkcollection.htm
BRAZIL REFERENCE SOUGHT
Ron Haller-Williams writes: "I want to verify a reference I
found. According to J A Golsalves de Mello (Rev.IAHGP
vol.48, 1976), the 3rd edition of Santos Leitão's "Catálogo
de Moedas Brasileiras" was published in 1941 (not 1940
as indicated in the list of earlier editions to be found at the
front of the 8th edition and onwards). Can anybody confirm
this? (from sight of the 3rd edition itself!)
Apparently, among the "moedas obsidionais" (siege-pieces),
it mentions one dated 1647, as well as the three values of
1645 & 1646. Can anybody confirm this? What does the
2nd edition (1933) say? Thanks very much. Replies direct
to moedas at heraldstar.u-net.com or, of course, via The
E-Sylum."
SUBSCRIBER PROFILE: TERRY TRANTOW
Terry Trantow writes "I joined the ANA as a junior in 1961
because I had been 'into' coin collecting with my Dad, with
a short gap, since 1953. Dad had a small container of Lincoln
cents from which we both built our penny collections in 1957,
missing only the 1909-S VDB and1914-D cents plus some
minor dates. I 'borrowed' out of that container as a kid on
a few occasions to buy a nickel candy bar, and he may have
been correct in 'suggesting' I spent some of those missing dates.
Due to my interest in history and being a consummate collector,
I discovered the field of medals, then tokens, and will always be
grateful to Charlie Kappen for his collaboration in producing the
work on So-Called Dollars in 1962, which set my direction into
token/medal collecting and for which I will always be in debt to
him. It would not surprise me to see continued works on tokens/
medals and its fraternity overshadow that of coin collecting."
EUROPEAN LIBRARIES
J. Moens of Belgium writes: " The following addresses might
interest Mr. Knepper for his trip to Europe :
- the "Cabinet des Médailles" of the Royal Library in Brussels
holds one of the finest collections of numismatic books in the
world. The collection can be consulted on-line at the following
site : http://www.kbr.be; go to "Catalogues connectés";
information about opening hours can be found under
"Départements et collections" and then under "Cabinet des
Médailles"
- the National Bank of Belgium has a good museum on the
history of money. Information can be found at
http://www.nbb.be, then "Museum"
Both institutions are situated in Brussels, at walking distance
(5 min.) from the Central Station."
COINING A PHRASE
In response to last week's question about the origin of
"Coin A Phrase", David Klinger and Jess Gaylor both
offered this history of the phrase from
http://www.wordorigins.org
"Sometimes interesting words a phrases are right under
our noses. After using it countless times on this site, a
reader asked me where the term to coin a phrase came from?
The verb to coin originally meant to literally mint a coin. It
dates to the 14th century. In the late-16th century, the sense
generalized to become to create or invent something. In
1940 the specific usage of coin a phrase came into use."
TOKEN MANUFACTURERS LOSING BIGGEST CUSTOMER.
Dick Johnson writes: "The commonest transportation token
for collectors have almost always been from New York City.
For token manufacturers NYC, their biggest customer,
won't be buying any more of the brass discs with the familiar
grill border with the pierced centers.
New York City's Metropolitan Transportation Authority said
Monday, January 13th, this is the end of the line for their
subway token (which also was used for surface buses and
Staten Island Railway fares). It took the first step to phase
out tokens and many of the booths at subway entrances
that dispense tokens: so long to the curt "How many?"
Also involved is the projected increase in price. Would you
believe they are floating a $2 per ride price? And how many
of us remember the ten-cent fare?
The token changed over the years. As prices increased
intermittently since 1953 so did the token varieties. Early
tokens of that period had the Y of NYC pierced out. When
the fare changed in 1970 the MTA kept the same design
-- and the same Y-shaped hole -- but increased the size. In
1979 they introduced a solid token (with a commemorative
design, really!) for a 75th anniversary.
Following 1980 and a new fare increase they kept a solid
token with no piercing. In 1986 incuse grill work with
round center hole and finally, in 1995 raised grill with
pentagon aperture.
What's coming are more Metro-Cards to be swiped at the
turnstiles. And $120 will give you unlimited rides for an
entire month. For their centennial next year, in 2004, will
the MTA issue a commemorative swipe card? No? How
about a Century of Straphanger Abuse Medal then?"
ST. NICK'S COINS?
While looking for other things on the web I came across
a reference to St. Nicholas delivering "bags of coins". Since
we just discussed St. Nick on paper money a few issues ago,
I thought I'd write it up. Is anyone familiar enough with the
origins of the figure to confirm that he delivered coins before
morphing into the modern concept of Santa Claus?
The article by Richard O'Mara was published January 5,
2003 in The Baltimore Sun. Titled "An American in Turkey"
it's a travelogue of a recent trip there.
"At Antalya, on the Turkish Riviera, we rested by the sea.
A museum there holds a relic, a bone from the jaw of a 4th-
century bishop thought to be the St. Nicholas who gave rise
to the legend of Santa Claus. He was known for providing
dowries to impoverished young girls, dropping bags of coins
down their chimneys."
http://www.sunspot.net/travel/bal-tr.turkey05jan05,0,774925.story?coll=bal-artslife-travel
PARANUMISMATICA DEFINED
Paul Withers writes: "Those who had not heard of the term
'paranumismatica' may like to read the following, taken from
"Alphabetical Classification f World Paranumismatica" by
Brian Edge which was written in 1977 and published by the
Token Corresponding Society - but read on and you will
discover more - even who 'coined the phrase' !
The very first problem encountered at the beginning of this
study was to find a blanket term, which could be adopted to
cover the many coin like objects, which for many years have
been loosely known as tokens. Numismatic Miscellanea,
and Numismatic Oddments were terms in fairly frequent use
and other collectors referred to these objects as Peripheral
Numismatics, Manablins, or just plain '0 & S" (Odds and
Sundries). In the United States many such items are known
as Exonumia. In view of all this, it was clear that it would be
necessary to coin a new word to describe this subsection of
numismatics and when, after considerable thought had been
given to the matter, TCS activist David Sealy mentioned a
word that he had invented there was little point in searching
further. The word was PARANUMISMATICA.
The ultimate object of this work is to produce a classification,
wherever possible under generic headings, of all items which
come within the bounds of world PARANUMISMATICA.
The term PARANUMISMATICA is to be interpreted as
any coin-like object, which is not in fact a coin. It may be
produced in metal, plastic, wood, etc , normally unofficial,
bearing an inscription, either with, or without a value. It is
acknowledged that many paper tokens exist, but, as they
are not coin-like objects, they have been disregarded.
It soon became apparent that different collectors used a
variety of terms to describe precisely the same thing. In
general, most of the terms were applied loosely, and
without any reasoning. The result of the practice was
considerable confusion and some items emerged with as
many as four different terms. For example the "To Hanover
Counters" were also known as "To Hanover Medalets",
"To Hanover Tokens" and "Cumberland Jacks"! This
problem occurred in so many cases that it became
abundantly clear that some form of standardisation was
necessary. In order to achieve this, all members of the
TOKEN CORRESPONDING SOCIETY were contacted
for their ideas in an effort to attain some form of agreement
about the application of the various terms.
From the resultant correspondence it was clear that there
would always be a few pieces which would never conform
to complete standardisation. A good example of this is the
Italian Telephone Token which bears the inscription "Gettone"
but which is not, in any way, a Jeton in the accepted sense
of the word. Allowing for such examples, the following list
of paranumismatic terms, which were generally accepted,
how proved to be applicable to virtually all PARANUMISMATICA.
Previous efforts to produce such a work as this by others
outside the TOKEN CORRESPONDING SOCIETY seem
to have been tackled without the necessary enthusiasm
required for the task, and the results haw been a hotchpotch
of listings. One of the main weaknesses has been hosts of
entries such as "Australian tokens", "Canadian tokens",
"Foreign tokens" and so on. These are, as I am sure you will
agree, very wide issues. Certainly, many of the entries in this
classification will have their origins in many different parts of
the world. If one takes the entry "Merchants and Store
Trading and Discount tokens" under SHOPS AND STORES
it will be realised that items will still come under this category,
whether they emanate from Australia, the U.S.A. or from
long suffering Ramsbottom! It is not necessary particularly
to distinguish one from the other as a separate entry in the
classification. The collector may decide to sort his tokens
from this particular category into, say, alphabetical order of
country of issue, then subdivide these into counties, towns or
cities within that country and then into particular trades or
businesses completely ad libatum. You will see, therefore,
that only one entry is actually required in the classification to
cover the lot.
We have certainly gone far since the first humble list appeared
in T.C.S Bulletin Volume 2 No. 1 in November 1973, which
was soon followed by No. 4 of that same Volume, in MAY/
JUNE 1974, with a piece entitled PARANUMISMATIC
REFERENCES. However, in spite of the obvious progress
that we have made, the listings are far from complete. There
must still be hundreds of missing entries and doubtless some
of these that are entered already are incorrectly positioned.
However, the exercise is falling into a general pattern, which
has for its skeleton about 42 generic headings so far. The
very fact that the author has been puzzling, sorting and
resorting for almost four years, has lead him to the conclusion
that it may well be a case now of not being able to see the
wood for trees! He, therefore, earnestly solicits from members
their constructive criticism of the work so far together with
additional entries with a view to the classification eventually
becoming the most detailed in existence."
Brian, as some token-interested readers may know, went on
to write "The First Dictionary of Paranumismatica. All about
Tokens, Checks, Medalets Counters, Tallies and Weights."
GARRETT LIBRARY?
In response to the query regarding possible NBS speakers
in Baltimore this summer, Nick Graver writes: "One fantastic
resource in Baltimore was the John Work Garrett Collection
at Johns Hopkins University. It was at Evergreen House (the
mansion), and was under the care of Sarah Elizabeth Freeman.
I attended a great meeting there in 1960 or 1961, shortly after
we moved there. (Certainly before we left in Spring 1963.)
There was a very distinguished scholar speaking, and the
exhibit of ancient gold was super. The collection was later
auctioned by Dave Bowers, and the staff must have been put
out to pasture. Who knows if any of the staff are there in
retirement, and if any of the numismatic library remains at
JHU?"
HELLENIC NUMISMATIC SOCIETY
In response to the question about the Hellenic Numismatic
Society, Kerry K. Wetterstrom Editor/Publisher of The
Celator reports: "The Hellenic Numismatic Society is still
very active and I just recently received their latest journal.
It is an excellent organization, especially important to the
collector of ancient Greek coinage."
Bill Daehn adds: "The Hellenic Numismatic Society is
indeed still active. I am a member. HNS continues to
publish an excellent annual journal, Nomismatika Kronika,
devoted to all aspects of Greek numismatics, but especially
strong in ancient Greek coinage. They also continue to
publish monographs on Greek numismatic topics. The
society has about 400 members around the world."
NAME CHANGES
Relating to our earlier discussions of the slight name change
for the American Numismatic Association's monthly journal,
Kerry adds: "By the way, in the spirit of making the ANA
more mainstream, it has now been suggested that they drop
the word "American" from the official organizational name.
"Numismatic Association" does have a nice ring to it!"
THE HOBBY OF "THE KING"
According to a January 3, 2003 Associated Press article,
one man says Elvis alive and collecting old coins. Here are
some excerpts - follow the link for the full article.
"Bill Beeny's roadside ''Elvis Is Alive'' museum serves up
plenty for folks with suspicious minds over whether Elvis
really ever left the building.
Barely bigger than a living room, the place about 40 miles
west of St. Louis is a conspiracy theorist's dream, from its
government documents to the pathology reports, DNA testing
results and photos, including one that purports to show Elvis
shadowing Muhammad Ali in 1984."
Beeny insists Elvis has surfaced in recent years--not at a
Kalamazoo, Mich., Burger King or as a Miami undercover
cop, as legend would have it, but as an arthritis sufferer who
in 1997 sought treatment from Dr. Donald W. Hinton, a
Kansas City, Mo., psychiatrist.
Supposedly with Elvis' help, Hinton co-wrote "The Truth
About Elvis Aron Presley, In His Own Words." Published
last year, the book chronicles the years since the King's
''death,'' saying it took Elvis three years to get clean and
sober.
Hinton says the King--now his pal--collects old coins and
American Indian artifacts, and isn't too shabby with fishing
gear.
http://www.jsonline.com/onwisconsin/music/jan03/107911.asp
FEATURED WEB SITE
This week's featured web site is recommended by W. David
Perkins of Mequon, Wisconsin. He writes: "I learned of a
new website this week that E-Sylum readers may want to
check out. I especially enjoyed exploring this site as it is
dedicated to one of my specialties, the study and collecting
of the early United States silver dollars 1794-1803.
Included in the site is an overview on the early dollars, with
high quality descriptions and illustrations all of the major types
and (Red Book) varieties of dollars. There are also "micro
photographs" of key features and differences in the varieties.
Also of interest to Bibliophiles are three publications, two
that appear to be available now and one in the works to be
published later in 2003. The two books available now are
Early Dollars: A Pocket Guide to Major Varieties and An
Introduction to Early Dollars, both published by the
Cardinal Collection Educational Foundation."
http://earlydollars.org
Wayne Homren
Numismatic Bibliomania Society
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a
non-profit organization promoting numismatic
literature. For more information please see
our web site at http://www.coinbooks.org/
There is a membership application available on
the web site. To join, print the application and
return it with your check to the address printed
on the application. For those without web access,
write to David Sklow, NBS Secretary-Treasurer,
P.O. Box 76192, Ocala, FL 34481.
For Asylum mailing address changes and other
membership questions, contact Dave at this email
address: sdsklow at aol.com
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum,
just Reply to this message, or write to the Editor
at this address: whomren at coinlibrary.com
(To be removed from the E-Sylum mailing list
send an email message with the word "Unsubscribe"
in the body of the message to:
esylum-request at binhost.com)
More information about the Esylum
mailing list