The E-Sylum v6#04, January 26, 2003
whomren at coinlibrary.com
whomren at coinlibrary.com
Sun Jan 26 20:16:31 PST 2003
Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 6, Number 4, January 26, 2003:
an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
Copyright (c) 2002, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
SUBSCRIBER UPDATE
Among recent new subscribers are Charles "Chick"
Ambrass, courtesy of Wayne Homren, and Don Scarinci,
courtesy of Dick Johnson. Welcome aboard! We now
have 516 subscribers.
NBS CALL FOR NOMINATIONS
NBS Board Member Tom Sheehan writes: "I would like
to publish a call for nominations for officers for NBS. I
would like to hear from anyone interested in running for
office or proposing another member for office. People
should reply to me directly. Your help in this is appreciated."
Tom's email address is twsheeh at attglobal.net
ASYLUM WINTER 2003 ISSUE READY
Tom Fort, editor of our print journal, writes: "The Winter 2003
issue of The Asylum is now in the final proofing stage and it
should be on its way to the printer during the week of
January 26-February 1. Readers will immediately see that the
journal has a somewhat new look and I welcome comments
either in The E-Sylum or sent to me directly [etfort at aol.com]
The Table of Contents is as follows:
"A Dissertation on the Allegorical Beings Found on the
Reverses of Medals," by Edward Gibbon [A rare essay by
the famous historian regarding a numismatic book he read in
1764. Unlike its only other publication, in 1815, our edition
is fully annotated with modern references and illustrated with
the coins Gibbon discusses.]
"A Thirty-Year Retrospective of Krause and Mishler:
Standard Catalog of World Coins," by William Malkmus
"A Few Notes On Translations," by Robert F. Fritsch
"Postcards as Numismatic Literature," by Pete Smith
"Changing Perspectives on American Numismatic Literature,"
by David F. Fanning
"David Block," by his friends and colleagues
"News from the Net." [with remembrances of the John W.
Adams sale]
"President's Message," by Pete Smith
"Letters to the Editor" (by Leonard Augsburger and Pete
Smith concerning Augsberger's article in the last issue)
"Editorial: De Historia et Numismatica," by E. Tomlinson
Fort [in which the editor opens his big mouth]
Also, we need material for the next issue. Those who would
like to submit something should try to have it to me by April 1
at the latest."
[I feel compelled at this point to interject an invitation for
those of you who aren't yet NBS members to consider
joining. The Asylum is sent only to paid-up members of
NBS. As this table of contents illustrates, there is a
world of great information contained within its pages.
-Editor]
Q. DAVID BOWERS CONTACT INFORMATION
Dave Bowers reports that "All is fine in the numismatic
research category and I look forward to creating a bunch
of new writing projects! My good wishes to all! My life
is all the richer for the many experiences and friendships
I have had in numismatics, including with many members
of the NBS, and I hope to be a vital part of 'the world's
greatest hobby' for many years to come."
He is no longer an employee of Bowers and Merena
Galleries or of Collectors Universe. He can be contacted
at the following addresses:"
Q. David Bowers
P.O. Box 539
Wolfeboro Falls, NH 03896-0539
e-mail: qdbarchive at metrocast.net
LAKE BOOKS SALE #67 READY
Fred Lake writes: "The 67th mail-bid sale of numismatic
literature from Lake Books is now available for viewing
on their web site at http://www.lakebooks.com/current.html.
The 546-lot catalog contains a wide variety of numismatic
material, including a long run of Ponterio auction catalogs,
many issues of the "Essay-Proof Journal", early "Redbooks",
Morgenthau auction catalogs, reference material on Tokens
and Medals, and many other subjects. The sale has a closing
date of February 11, 2003."
MOULTON JANUARY 2003 FIXED PRICE LIST #1
Karl Moulton's latest fixed price list has been published.
Covering American numismatic auction catalogs from
1860 to date, the list is the most comprehensive of its
kind. Karl's annotations are great references in themselves.
One good example is the 12/16/1880 Charles A. Besson
sale by John W. Haseltine. Karl writes: "this sale .. contains
an 1838-O Half Dollar. You will not find this offering of
an 1838-O Half Dollar mentioned in anyone's pedigrees
in any references because no one has taken the time to
check. According to Haseltine's information, at this
juncture, there were six examples known." For more
information, see Karl's web site: http://www.coincats.com/
ANS LIBRARY ENDOWMENT DRIVE LAUNCHED
John W. Adams writes: "Great News!! The American
Numismatic Society has accelerated its building schedule.
We now plan to complete renovations of our new
downtown location by September 30th and move in by year
end. What this means, in practical terms, is that the world's
greatest Numismatic Library will soon become easily
accessible. For bibliophiles everywhere, the move represents
a major milestone.
In celebration of this event, the Library Committee has
launched a drive to fund the Francis D. Campbell Library Chair.
Frank, as many of you know, is our all-star librarian these past
27 years; he combines encyclopedic knowledge with a rare
service ethic. We have two objectives: 1) to raise $2,000,000
to endow the Librarian's position and 2) to reach out to a broad
constituency to be symbolized by a minimum of 500 contributors.
Where do the readers of E-Sylum fit in? We want your money,
of course, in large or in small amounts. The 516 readers of The
E-Sylum could by themselves fulfill our breadth objective.
However, we also seek your support in spreading the gospel far
and wide. The A.N.S. Library is (or should be) to bibliophiles
what the World Cup is to soccer fans. We need your help
in raising awareness of numismatic literature to a new level.
Checks should be made payable to the American Numismatic
Society and designated for the Francis D. Campbell Library
Chair either on the check or in an accompanying note.
Send to The American Numismatic Society, Broadway at
155th St., New York, NY 10032. For those who have an
interest in playing a more active role, contact me at
jadams at ahh.com or contact anyone you know on our
committee:
Catherine E. Bullowa-Moore
Frank Campbell
Dan Hamelberg
George F. Kolbe
Joseph R. Lasser
Harrington E. Manville
Richard Margolis
David & Susan Tripp
Anthony Terranova
Randolph Zander"
1852 MICKLEY DIARY ENTRIES PUBLISHED
Readers may recall last year's April Fools item in the
March 31, 2002 E-Sylum (v5n14) titled "MICKLEY
MYSTERY". The item implied that diaries of the
great American collector Joseph Mickley had been
found. For years, only one volume of Mickley's diaries
was known - the 1866-69 volume found by George Kolbe
and sold to Armand Champa. Your editor spent a wonderful
afternoon during a visit to Louisville reading through the
diary (and other great numismatic rarities) in Armand's
library. It now resides in the ANS Library, courtesy of
Harry Bass. One of the great mysteries of American
numismatic literature is the fate of the remaining volumes
of Mickley's diaries.
NBS Board member Joel J. Orosz got the joke. His
article on Jacob Giles Morris in The Numismatist had
contained what was for me a real bombshell - Joel had
managed to locate another volume of Mickley's diaries!
No joke! Joel shared the story of his discovery of the
volume in the April 28, 2002 E-Sylum (v5n18).
While the rest of us were having fun at the 2000 Philadelphia
ANA Convention, Joel slipped away to the manuscript
repository of the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, where
he discovered the 1852 volume. Now that's MY kind
of fun.
The latest issue of the American Numismatic Society's
American Journal of Numismatics [Second Series 13
(2001)], just published, contains Joel's newest article titled
"Joseph J. Mickley's Diary for 1852: An Annotated
Transcription." From Joel's preface:
"William Du Bois's observation that Mickley had kept a
journal "nearly all his life" suggests that there was once an
unbroken string of such volumes, stretching backward from
his death in 1878 to the 1830's or even the 1820's. Because
our knowledge of numismatic history in the United States
prior to the widespread popularization of the hobby in the
late 1850s is sketchy at best, the Mickley diaries from the
early years would comprise the numismatic analogue of the
Dead Sea scrolls. The first-hand testimony to be found within
could settle many arguments and illuminate dark corners. The
only problem is that, even with the discovery of the 1852
diary, the vast majority of Mickley's volumes are still "missing
masterpieces".
It seems probable that other volumes of the Mickley diaries
may still exist, if for no other reason than that a systematic
search has never been mounted for them."
Here's one excerpt from the diary:
"Friday, May 28, 1852 Went to see Mr. Peale at the Mint
who gave me two Proof Half Dollars of the year 1838, on
the obverse is a beautiful Head by the late C. Gobrecht
(then Dyesinker [sic] of the Mint) on [the] Reverse on [sic]
has a Flying Eagle & the other an eagle without the Shield."
Joel's annotations make the article a delight for numismatic
bibliophiles and researchers. Thanks, Joel!
MEDALIST MARCEL JOVINE DIED THIS WEEK.
Dick Johnson writes: "Marcel Jovine, who raised the bar
for American medallic art by his highly creative and detailed
medallic designs, died Monday, January 20, 2003 in
Greenwich, Connecticut. He was 81.
Jovine was born in Italy, captured in World War II and
brought to America as a prisoner-of-war. Repatriated to
Italy, he returned to America in 1946, determined to make
a career of his sculptural talents. He is noted for his coin
designs -- the earliest of which for the 1987 U.S.
Constitution $5 gold commemorative -- he was allowed
to do both sides.
For the half dozen other commemorative coins he was
only allowed to do one side. But it was his medallic art
where he truly excelled. He did two regular issues for The
Society of Medalists including an oversized concave-convex
"Creation" and the American Bicentennial tribute, "Yankee
Doodle." No other artist made three medals for The Society.
His 15-year series for the Medallic Art Company Calendar
Medal Series was noted for extremely detailed designs, often
running around the edge of the medal in an unbroken circle.
These always had strong visual themes: American Bicentennial,
Old Glory, Zodiac, Sailing Ships, Olympic Winter Games,
Flight, American Automobile, Statue of Liberty, Pegasus
and the American Circus.
He will also be long remembered for his space medals, a
twin medal set for the Viking I and II Mars Landing
achievement, and the U.S. Russian Apollo-Soyuz Space
Medal. The later was so creative the legend was in English
on one side and in Russian on the other. He even signed his
name on both sides, once in English, once in Russian.
He did two medals for the United States Capitol Historical
Society, and a string of medals for other American medal
series. One of those was seven medals of Charles Lindbergh,
and six for the Pasadena California Centennial.
Among numismatists, however, his memory will exist for
centuries for perhaps the most notable numismatic medallic
work of the 20th century. This was the American Numismatic
Society's 125th Anniversary Plaquette in which he replicated
dozens of the most famous coins and medals from the
Society's collections. I have chosen this work as the
frontispiece of my upcoming directory of American Artists.
This piece projects the essence of numismatics and vivifies the
field we all hold dear in a stunning work of medallic art!
Thank you, Marcel, I will miss your jolly, convivial friendship."
GARRETT NUMISMATIC LIBRARY UPDATE
Joel Orosz writes: "Regarding Nick Graver's query about
whether the Garrett numismatic library is still in Evergreen
House, I can authoritatively state that it was in residence as
of March of 1995, when I paid the house a visit. The
collection was mainly a working library of catalogues and
the standard references of the 1880s--I don't recall seeing
any special editions or sumptuous bindings. The numismatic
books were not in the large library addition (below which
the coin vault is located), but rather in the original portion
of the house, on bookshelves in two large parlor rooms.
Whether they are still there, I cannot say. I wrote up my
visit, under the title of "John Work Garrett, Evergreen House,
and Me," which was published in Bowers and Merena's Rare
Coin Review No. 110 (March/April 1996)."
GUNTER KIENAST SOUGHT
Dale Krueger writes: "Does anyone know what ever happened
to Gunter Kienast, author of the two books on Karl Goetz and
his medals? Is he still alive? I've heard rumors that he may
have passed on, and other rumors that he's down in Florida
playing shuffleboard with some Guido medals. Someone's got
to know. Thanks."
NOTES FROM MIKE GREENSPAN
Mike Greenspan writes: "Two quick items: Relative to the
book review of "Greenback:...": As a former "insider," I
recall that, in the recent past (not more than ten years ago or
so), the IRS seized the Mustang Ranch, Nevada's notorious
brothel, in a tax case, and allowed it to continue to operate
(legally in Nevada). Strange things happen in government.
Relative to Dick Johnson's comments on NYC subway
tokens and the early ten-cent fare, let me say that he is obviously
younger than I. I clearly remember using a nickel in the
subway turnstile in the late 1940's and perhaps as late as 1952,
prior to the use of any tokens. Now, if can remember where
I put my car keys............"
FANNING HUNLEY ARTICLE ONLINE
David Fanning writes: "My article on nondestructive testing
of the Hunley posted to my employer's Web site. It's a PDF,
which people can download (we stripped the ads out, so if it
looks a little weird, that's why). The article is posted at
http://www.asnt.org/publications/materialseval/fanning.pdf
with a link also from
http://www.asnt.org/publications/materialseval/materialseval.htm.
The article contains a few cool photos, including one right after
Maria Jacobsen found Dixon's lucky double eagle."
SPINGARN MEDAL REFERENCES
Dick Johnson writes: "I sold the NAACP's Spingarn Medal
twice. Once in my Johnson & Jensen auction number 11 on
August 17, 1981 lot 277 where it realized $95 (against a
$50-60 estimate) and again in a double auction 15-16 on
March 28, 1982 lot 1309 where it sold for $71.50 against
the same estimate. It was illustrated in both auction catalogs.
Obverse bore a blind Justice holding aloft scales in her right
hand with left hand holding the hilt of a sword point down;
with sun and rays behind. Reverse is the medal name
superimposed on a wreath with four lines of lettering divided
by a fairly large reserve (the blank area on a medal intended
for inscribing recipient's name and award details), with wings
below. In both instances the medal was unsigned, unawarded
and the maker was unknown to me then (and now!). I would
be delighted to learn who, indeed, was the artist and who
struck it (and would gladly add this data to my upcoming
directory of American Artists, Diesinkers, Engravers,
Medalists and Sculptors).
The design is quite good and the striking exhibits an
experienced maker. If I had to guess (and I shouldn't) it is in
the style of Julio Kilenyi (and possibly struck by Whitehead &
Hoag). Both are gone with no records surviving, so any
documented data will have to come from the NAACP itself.
The fact the highest award for black Americans was probably
modeled by a white person is evidence of the scarcity of black
medalists. In my databank of 3,350 American artists I have
listed only eight black Americans that I can identify. The most
famous of all was Richmond Barthe (1901-1989). Medallic
Art Company struck three of his medals before World War II.
(I remember our art department contacting him in the 1960s to
do additional medals but to no avail.)
My list also includes Selma Hortense Burke (1907-1995)
who claimed John R. Sinnock stole her relief of Franklin D.
Roosevelt for the design of the Roosevelt Dime. I have
examined a photograph of her Roosevelt relief and it no
way aligns with Sinnock's dime model. His work is entirely
original. Walter Breen mentions Selma Burke in his
Encyclopedia, and she must have repeated this story often,
because it is mentioned in every one of her biographies.
Robert Van Ryzin wrote an article on her and her relief in
Numismatic News 30 November 1973."
Joe Levine of Presidential Coin & Antique Company writes:
"This appeared in our Auction #70, #711. I believe the correct
spelling in Spingarn, nor Springard."
"NAACP SPINGARN AWARD MEDAL, (1914) 62.8mm.
Gilt Bronze. Unsigned. XF/AU, with a suspension loop applied
at top. There is a bit of darkening on the medal immediately
below where the loop was applied. The obverse features a
standing figure of Justice holding balance scales aloft with her
right hand and a sword in her left. A radiant sun is in the
background. Inscribed at lower left is, FOR/ MERIT. On the
reverse, a cartouche inscribed SPINGARN MEDAL is
superimposed over a wreath enclosing the lamp of learning.
Below: AWARDED TO with an empty space for engraving
the name of the awardee. At bottom is a three line inscription:
BY THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION/ FOR THE
ADVANCEMENT/ OF COLORED PEOPLE above a pair
of wings to either side of a flame.
The National Association for the Advancement of Colored
People (NAACP) awards the Spingarn Medal annually to a
black American who has achieved career excellence. This
award was established in 1914 by Joel Elias Spingarn
(1875-1939), who was then chairman of the NAACP board
of directors. He was a literary critic who was one of the first
white members of the NAACP. Spingarn taught literature at
Columbia University and encouraged the development of
black writers during the Harlem Renaissance of the 1920s.
As the medal is awarded in gold, we presume that this is a
specimen strike. This is one of the more important medals
relating to African-American history. The winners of the
award read like a Who's Who of twentieth century black
America. A rare medal - it is the first we have seen. (G)
7001. #711. Gilt Bronze. XF/AU looped. $219.00"
Gar Travis located several web references for us, including
some background on Spingarn from the online Worldbook
Encyclopedia (http://www2.worldbook.com/)
Gar provided links to some pictures of the medal.
Unfortunately, none is a close-up of the medal itself.
"Marian Anderson with Springarn Medal and Eleanor Roosevelt"
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/odyssey/archive/08/0812001r.jpg
"A later image of Marian Anderson with the medal"
http://home.wanadoo.nl/gregquast/imwebsite.jpg/NAACP.jpg
"Bad image, but an image nevertheless and an unmentioned recipient."
http://www.blackvoices.com/feature/bhm_00/science.htm
ENCYCLOPEDIAS BACK FROM THE DEAD
Speaking of encyclopedias, a Boston Globe article
on December 30, 2002 reported that despite the
pounding they took from electronic media, the good
old-fashioned hardcopy encyclopedia is enjoying a
revival of sorts. Long live the book!
"In its knotty-pine bookcase, the encyclopedia remained a
kind of home intellectual center for decades. A thousand
times we heard ''Look it up in the Britannica'' when we had
a question or homework assignment, even after the battered
row of brown volumes was long outdated.
That story is legion in America, though the brand might be
Compton's, World Book, or Americana. In today's online
world, however, one might reasonably consider the row of
dignified volumes a quaint relic, like glass milk bottles or the
slide rule.
But the surprising fact is that printed encyclopedias are not
only still around, they seem to be enjoying a modest revival.
Publishers are rediscovering how to reach the customer who
thinks a printed book is still the best source of knowledge.
After a four-year hiatus, Encyclopaedia Britannica, based in
Chicago, has almost sold out the new edition it released this
year and is planning a revision for next year. Libraries remain
the best customers, but there is still a core of people who
want that row of books at home."
"But just as radio survived television and records didn't kill
off live performances, the printed encyclopedia stuck around.
''People were still asking about the print set,'' says Patti Ginnis,
Britannica's sales director. Schools and libraries still wanted
encyclopedias, and individuals like Schiebler continued to
order them. ''It wasn't huge,'' Ginnis says, ''but it did make us
sit up and take notice. It made us realize that people were
still interested.''
Britannica began to showcase the print set on its Web site
and to sell it in booths at state fairs and all kinds of
professional trade shows with surprising success."
"A 2002 study of research habits by Outsell Inc., a market
research company based in San Francisco, found that while
people will use the Internet for a fast information search,
they tend to place more trust in a book."
''One significant finding was that print is the preferred format
for using content, though not the preferred format for finding it,''
http://www.boston.com/dailyglobe2/364/living/Encyclopedias_still_speak_volumes+.shtml
JETON, ZHETON, GETTONE
In response to Paul Withers' note on "the Italian Telephone
Token which bears the inscription "Gettone", Martin Purdy
writes: "This is probably also a good example of a "false friend":
"gettone" is the standard Italian word for a token or a counter,
not (or not necessarily) a jeton per se. The word has spread
to other countries and cultures with the meaning "token", too:
just today I saw a Russian 1975 mint set that had, on the case,
the words "Leningrad mint's [sic] token" in English; the parallel
Russian text used the word "Zheton", quite clearly derived
from French "jeton", for "token"."
KRAUSE CLOSEOUTS
Peter Mosiondz, Jr. writes: "I thought some of our bibliophiles
might be interested in the following closeouts from Edward R.
Hamilton, Bookseller (http://www.edwardrhamilton.com
#2255243 Medallic Portraits of Washington, 2nd ed, $1.95
#2223961 Hard Times Tokens, 6th edition $1.95
#2218496 Latin American Tokens $1.95
#216633X Standard Guide to Paper Money, 2nd ed $2.95
Apparently Krause is cleaning (ware)house. I am told that
my own book "Successful Stamp Dealing" will soon be
remaindered as well. I am planning to work on a revised
edition of it along with "Successful Coin Dealing" that I
plan to publish through J.T. Stanton in the not too distant
future."
NUMISMATIC PROPHECY.
Medal Maven Dick Johnson writes: "Wow! Terry Trantow,
may I repeat your quote (from last week's E-Sylum)?
"It would not surprise me [in the future] to see continued
works on tokens/medals and its fraternity overshadow that of
coin collecting."
Somehow I have felt this for a long time. Terry, are you
clairvoyant?"
CANADIAN NATIONAL LIBRARY FLOODS (AGAIN)
The Canadian National Library in Ottowa seems to have a
little problem with flooding -- not a good thing for a library.
On the web site of the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. is an
article about the problem. Here's a excerpt. Follow the
link for the complete article.
"A flood cleanup wasn't on the National Library's list of 50th
anniversary preparations. But the extreme cold burst a pipe
Tuesday, sending staff into a salvage mode that is all too
familiar.
Staff at the library say they're getting good at drying out
books, but it's not a skill they're proud of
As staff dealt with the rogue water, retired librarians
gathered for pictures to mark the library's half-century of
operations.
In the last decade there have been about 70 floods in the
building on Wellington Street..."
http://ottawa.cbc.ca/template/servlet/View?filename=ot_natlib20030123
ONE-TO-ONE LIBRARIES
Document and autograph dealer Kenneth Rendell
published some thoughts a couple years ago on the effect that
the internet is having on bibliophiles. The article appeared
in Business 2.0 (September 26, 2000). The full text is
available at this address:
http://www.business2.com/articles/mag/0,1640,14038,FF.html
"The major libraries of the future are being formed right
now, and the Internet in particular and technology in
general are important ingredients. "
"Few of these libraries are even slightly known to the public...
While the sources of historical letters and manuscripts have
always been relatively few, and collectors of original writings
have been more individual in their approach, collecting books
has always been greatly influenced by the supply system. If
you were interested in people or subjects out of the
mainstream, and there was no dealer specializing in the area,
you would have a very difficult time collecting. Dealers
wouldn't buy non-mainstream books for their stocks and
certainly couldn't afford to risk catalog space on books of
unproven interest.
The Internet has revolutionized this. The books that you want
to put together on a particular subject may be scattered among
several hundred dealers throughout the world, and they may
not be expensive enough to appear in printed catalogs, but by
using the Net, you can find them in the most efficient way. "
FEATURED WEB SITE
This week's featured web site is the International Olympic
Numismatic Federation. "The "Fédération Internationale
de Numismatique Olympique", better known as FINO, is
an official Olympic Federation founded by the president of
the IOC on 24 March, 1993. Headquartered in Lausanne,
Switzerland, its purpose is to bring together people and
organisations with an interest in Olympism, pursuing this
interest through the collection and study of coins, bank notes,
medals and tokens."
http://www.collectors.olympic.org/e/fino/index2.html
Wayne Homren
Numismatic Bibliomania Society
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a
non-profit organization promoting numismatic
literature. For more information please see
our web site at http://www.coinbooks.org/
There is a membership application available on
the web site. To join, print the application and
return it with your check to the address printed
on the application. For those without web access,
write to David Sklow, NBS Secretary-Treasurer,
P.O. Box 76192, Ocala, FL 34481.
For Asylum mailing address changes and other
membership questions, contact Dave at this email
address: sdsklow at aol.com
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum,
just Reply to this message, or write to the Editor
at this address: whomren at coinlibrary.com
(To be removed from the E-Sylum mailing list
send an email message with the word "Unsubscribe"
in the body of the message to:
esylum-request at binhost.com)
More information about the Esylum
mailing list